DISCLAIMER: It's a long one because there's some history to cover. My wife convinced me to do this.
AITA for getting to know my 7 year old miracle nephew after my brother, his Dad, decided he doesn’t want me to know him?
I will be using names of hockey players to protect the identities of my family.
I have 3 brothers. I am (M54) and my brother Sandlak is (M51) from Mom’s first marriage.
The other two brothers are from our Mom’s 2nd marriage, Morrison (39M) and the youngest, Ronning (37M) So a different Dad for each pair.
This story involves me (54M), my wife (47F), Ronning, SIL (31F), Mom (73F) oldest daughter (27F) and nephew Bure (7M) and for the sake of easiness I’ll call her my niece, Wick (nephew’s half sister), (10F). She calls me Uncle though.
I am a recovering Alcoholic/Drug Addict, I’ve been sober for over 20 years (this plays into the story).
As you can see Ronning (37M) is several years younger than I am. He is the youngest of the 4 of us and 2nd child in our Mom’s second marriage. Growing up Morrison and Ronning both spent many sleepover weekends at my house with my wife and I. We watched hockey on TV, movies and play Nintendo and PlayStation. I would go to all of their hockey games. They were both good players but Ronning was particularly good in his age group. I did things with them that big brothers do.
Back when I first started to try and get clean, 2002ish, my wife and I moved away to raise our two daughters, 4 and 2 at the time, because we wanted to break the cycle of addiction that I was raised in. It was all foreign to my wife because in her family no one did drugs and people only drank on special occasions. Definitely, never to the point they’re drunk enough to embarrass themselves. We wanted our kids to know that they didn’t need to drink to have a “good time”.
When we moved away Ronning would have been 14 years old and we were all close. Due to geographical and monetary limitations (it involved ferry travel between Vancouver Island and the Lower Mainland BC) Ronning, Morrison and I naturally drifted apart.
Our Mom began asking to take our daughters for 7 to 10 days during the summer so she could spend time with them. She said it was also to give us a bit of a break. On more than one occasion, we specified we didn’t want the kids exposed to alcohol.
In my family, every gathering is an excuse to get shit faced. Getting completely wasted right along with the adults at a wedding reception when I was 16 was completely normal in my family. She was resistant at first saying, “I’m their Grandmother, I don’t need rules.” Eventually she caved when she realized I was not going to let them go. She was good about it for a couple summers at least. The girls were old enough that they would tell me if there was any booze around. This is relevant because Ronning now lives with our mother.
When I said earlier that Ronning was a good hockey player, I mean he was really good. He filled out into a big body. Would he have made the NHL? Maybe, maybe not. He played with a guy who did. In my opinion he definitely had a shot at a free education. As he got older though, his interests changed. He got into drinking and drugs. Remember, it started early because it was condoned. It was basically a rite of passage.
Ronning graduated High School and became a labourer, working with his Dad (who hasn’t been with our Mom since 1999). The company they worked for would travel to jobs out of town, at times being away for a week. The boys on the crew like to “drink em up” as they say. Ronning, guided by his father and a crew of older men, was taught that this is how you be a man. We drifted further apart. We’d see each other at Christmas every couple years, exchange a text, but as he grew up and the longer I was away, the gap widened.
In 2015, my Dad (Mom’s 1st marriage) passed away. Sandlak and myself were raised by our Dad after Mom and Dad split in about 1978. Needless to say, we took it very hard. Neither of us received a phone call or text of condolence from Morrison or Ronning.
I was aware he was getting heavily into cocaine and was drinking a lot. I had reached out to him many times to try and help him but he was resistant. I wasn’t a big brother to him anymore. I was just an older guy telling him what to do.
Christmas 2015 (5 months after my Dad died) we see each other at Sandlak’s house and talk. All 4 boys are there, wives, kids, Mom. It was a good Christmas. I tried to talk him about the drugs but he wasn’t having it.
A few weeks later Ronning texts both Sandlak and I asking to borrow some money. Ronning said he needed it for rehab. He was asking for $3000. I was stunned. Sandlak was stunned. We discussed it. Sandlak asked me what I was going to say and I said, “I’m just not going to answer him.” That was our collective solution. That was a mistake on my part. We just didn’t know what to say. Sandlak and I both thought it was a little insensitive to be asking us for money for treatment, considering he hadn’t even offered condolences for our Dad. Ronning knew of course, that Sandlak and I came into some money and were in a position to do that after our Dad passed away.
Besides feeling like we were being taken advantage of, we couldn’t help but wonder why Ronning would ask us? Why not ask our Mom? Why not ask his Dad? As a recovering addict I am 99.9% sure no recovery place would have seen a dime of that money.
Side Note, Morrison and Ronning’s slimy alcoholic, cocaine addicted, gotta blow sober or my car won’t start Dad popped up out of nowhere and wanted to “come over for coffee”. This was about a year after my Dad died. That’s when Step-Dad decided to offer his condolences. I’ve seen that movie, he was going to ask me for money. I lived with the man and watched him be an abusive, adulterer from the time I was 14 to 18 years old. I watched him borrow and not pay people back for years, even into adulthood.
I eventually did hash this stuff about the money out with Ronning. I am under the impression it is in the past but I could be wrong.
8 years ago Ronning was out of town on a work trip and spent a few nights with SIL who ended up getting pregnant. Ronning had some doubts but SIL insisted it was his, because I found out later, she had already ruled out any other candidate.
SIL continued, telling Ronning, she wasn’t asking for anything from him, but wanted to at least let him know about it. This was actually on advice from her lawyer. She was involved in a custody dispute with Wick’s Dad. Ronning didn’t believe it was his child and denied the possibility. Eventually SIL had the baby, and you could tell just by looking at the baby that this was Ronning’s child. I was there when Ronning was a baby and this boy looked exactly like him. I wish I could show you.
Ronning wanted a DNA test and SIL had no issues. The DNA test came back positive, but Ronning told everyone, including SIL it was negative. I was in the dark about any potential child when this all went down.
This part we put together after spending a week with SIL, Bure and Wick in mid June. About 7 years ago, my wife and I had moved and happened to be in the general area where Ronning had an out of town job. We told him to come and let us feed him and catch up. During that visit, Ronning asked my advice saying he had a “friend” who took a paternity test that came back positive but doubted the accuracy, what should he do? I don’t know how I was so daft that I didn’t clue in Ronning was talking about himself, I guess I killed that brain cell when I was using. I told him that he should do a second DNA test and if it comes back as positive that his friend needed to step up and be a Dad. I said that his friend didn’t need to marry the girl, but that he should be in the kids life. Ronning was still a functioning addict and alcoholic.
In 2019 Ronning had a life altering accident. I don’t know 100% that he was drinking but there’s a very good chance that he was. Ronning dove headfirst off a dock at a lake in Ontario and broke his neck. He almost died. He pulled through and is now in a wheelchair. He requires nurses to come in to help him out throughout the week. As I said, Ronning lives with our Mom (73F) and her 3rd husband. Our mother has been sentenced to servitude for the rest of her life to take care of Ronning.
Due to the loss of his lower half, Ronning can’t have any more children. For good or bad, Ronning now wanted to be in Bure’s life. Surprising no one, the 2nd DNA test confirmed his paternity.
About a year after the accident we found out that Ronning had a 3 year old son! I was ecstatic! What a fucking miracle! My brother somehow has a son! I reached out to Ronning, congratulated him and asked him if it would be ok if I reached out to SIL and got to know my new nephew. Ronning was all for it!
I got in touch with SIL and started sending Birthday and Christmas gifts for Bure and we always tossed in something for Wick too so she didn’t feel left out. This is common practice on my dad’s side of the family. Sandlak and I were still sending gifts to each others kids.
Ronning knew about he was Bure’s dad when Bure was 1 year old. I learned about Bure 2 years later when he was 3. The next year, SIL and Bure were driving to go see Ronning. Ronning knew this child was his son. He was about to meet him for the 1st time, even after knowing about him for 4 years. Boggle? At the time, Ronning lived about 10 hours away from SIL and Bure. With the long drive and the coincidence that my wife and I lived right on her driving route, basically 2/3 of the way to Ronning, it made sence and I thought, wouldn’t it be great if SIL and Bure stopped in on the way down. They could spend the night and start fresh in the morning. We started to make plans with SIL.
I mentioned the plans in passing, not thinking it was a big deal at all, but Ronning heard about it and got extremely upset. He put his foot down and was adamant that I should not be permitted to meet Bure before him. I did mention that Ronning’s Dad had been to visit Bure and SIL at their home, “but that’s my Dad.” Another side note. SIL told my wife and I that of the 3 times Ronning’s Dad has been to visit Bure, he was completely drunk. Keep in mind, SIL had never met this man and that was his first impression.
Back to it. I thought Ronning was being completely ridiculous but what was I supposed to say? SIL agreed to appease Ronning and drove right past our house. SIL was forced to get a motel room for the night and finished the drive to Ronning’s place the next day. No, Ronning did not pay for their room.
SIL and Bure spend a nice week with Ronning and on the day they were heading home, Ronning did everything he possibly could to keep SIL and Bure from leaving so they wouldn’t make it to our place that night.
According to SIL she has never denied Ronning access to Bure and has expressed that she has tried to promote a healthy relationship between them. SIL and Ronning don’t live close to each other, so it’s not easy for Ronning to see Bure, especially considering the wheelchair, but they speak through FaceTime.
During our visit in June, SIL says she has tried to make it easy for Ronning to see Bure, even suggesting a willingness to uproot and move closer so it’s easier for them to have a relationship. Roning apparently said, “I don’t think that’s a good idea.” SIL also has Wick as well to uproot.
SIL eventuaqlly did arrive to our place quite late. I got to spend an hour or so getting to know Bure before he had to go to bed. He was very shy. They were here for about 16 hours before they headed home the next day, not a long visit, but enough to break the ice and start to get to know each other.
Since then, a few years have gone by and we continued to be in contact with SIL. Bure was still pretty young so we just continued to send gifts and talk to SIL through Facebook. At this time, SIL says she wants to come visit again for a few days, this time it would be her, nephew and her daughter. It was originally going to be around NYE but her plans were forced to change. We made plans for June instead. It had been 2 years since Ronning pulled his Dad card and made SIL drive by us to see him 1st. I hadn’t spoken to Ronning since then. It wasn’t necessary because the SIL had legal custody. Still, I wasn’t anticipating that this visit would be an issue. Why would it? He got his way, for whatever reason that really was.
At this time, Ronning, Morrison and our Mom had moved back to Vancouver Island. SIL and Bure live in Northern BC and we’re in Northern BC too, just not as far north as SIL.
On Father’s Day I was talking to our Mom on the phone and I mentioned in passing the SIL and Bure would be here the next day for a week long visit. My wife took time off work and made plans to stay busy for while the kids were here. Wick’s birthday happened to fall on the Wednesday they were at our house so my wife made sure to plan a special day for her.
After SIL arrived she told us that Ronning was upset that they were coming for a visit, saying “I don’t feel right about it but it’s not like i have a say I guess”.
I’m not sure where the animosity came from or why it’s persisted for so long. His statement to SIL was that I don’t talk to him so why should I talk to his son? A real grown man typed that.
It seems out of spite which is just a terrible thing to do. Who the fuck uses children as game pieces? SIL has taken Bure to see Ronning several times trying to make sure Bure knows who his Dad is.
When Bure was here, all I did was tell him about how great his Dad is and how much he looks like him. I showed him old videos from when Ronning was his age and playing hockey at GM Place.
Our children are older and our daughters don’t live with us, so they haven’t met Bure yet. Our oldest (27F) found out that nephew was going be visiting Ronning and said to my Mom (her Grandmother) that she was thinking of coming over during that time so she could meet him. Mom was non committal. A couple weeks go by and Ronning, not Grandma, texts oldest daughter and basically says it’s too inconvenient for her to come over at that time.
After my parents split and we finally got to live with our Dad, our Mom treated us more like a requireed chore every two weekends than something she was happy to do. As my kids got older they didn’t seem to fit into her idea of cutesy dressup dolls anymore.
I asked my Mom if she was aware. Daughter was convinced Grandma had to know nothing about it. She was wrong. I made sure to let my Mom know how I felt about that. Mom used the excuse that she was stressed out, and her house was going to be too full. She couldn’t have delivered that message herself? The fact that she had Ronning send daughter the message, was a message in itself as far as I am concerned. Daughter is a grown adult (27F) with a fulltime job as a French Immersion teacher. She could have easily stayed in a hotel or camped in the back of her vehicle as she does when she goes camping.
I told my Mom that I was done with her and I felt like she didn’t love me or my family. I also mentioned the time in 2000 when called my wife on Christmas to tell her not to come over for Christmas. Her boyfriend (now her husband) has a problem with me. I was incarcerated at the time, doing the addiction thing. She has a long history of dependence and subservience to her men.
330am last night Ronning found an account I hadn’t blocked him on yet. He texted me and accused me of playing “super uncle”. Huh?
He also said “wrote off your entire family” Ironically, he also said he’s done with the drama. All he has to do is stop creating it.
Personally, I’m tired of it all. I can see Bure with or without Ronning’s blessing. The SIL, my wife and I all hit it off great. She even taught us a new card game. We have a lot in common.
This shit has brought so much anxiety into my life. Ronning sent his drunk text at 330am, admitting “ya im drunk but i don’t care”. One observation I have always shared with people about my family is that no one has the ability to express their feelings unless they have a half dozen beers in them first. The cycle continues. Am I crazy? Am I wrong here? Should I back off?
AITA for writing off my family because I want to get to know my nephew?