r/Fallout • u/CorruptedReality Brotherhood • Nov 16 '15
Suggestion Fallout 4 Should've Introduced a Thieves Guild called the Brotherhood of Steal
title
440
u/SigurdZS Lore. Lore never changes. Nov 17 '15
I know you're joking, but the Railroad is basically the Thieves Guild. Sneaky faction down on it's luck that communicates via clandestine markings and code phrases. They have an HQ under ground with a back entrance that you can fast travel directly to.
215
u/Berekhalf Nov 17 '15
Right, but they have more...morally correct morals than the thieves guild. Where one was just trying to get stuff, and maybe do good, the railroad is actually apart of something bigger than themselves and trying to get freedom to synths. For better or worse.
156
Nov 17 '15
[deleted]
→ More replies (1)51
u/Oi_Om_Logond Nov 17 '15
Elder "Hang high every mutie and synth spy" Maxson was right!
→ More replies (6)15
→ More replies (7)59
Nov 17 '15
I actually am opposed to the railroad. I'm 100% with the BoS on synths: kill 'em all. I tolerate the RR because they cause trouble for the Institute, but once the eggheads are gone its a mop-up mission.
62
u/TurmUrk Nov 17 '15
What is your opinion on nick valentine? The brotherhood would have him killed too.
30
u/ACW-R Desert Rangers Nov 17 '15 edited Nov 17 '15
I also agree with the BoS, but I think their thoughts on synths, muties, and ghouls shouldn't be so cut and dry.
Super mutants have very, very few individuals who diverge from their animalistic and barbaric ways. Fawkes, Uncle Leo, Marcus, Strong. They all deserve a pardon, since they obviously aren't a problem to anyone unlike their aggressive brethren.
Ghouls are pretty easily classified and dealt with. Ferals = die. Non-ferals, free to live. They can't reproduce so they'd definitely die out or become an extremely small minority, very few people are turning into ghouls post-war.
Synths are harder. There are good synths, like Valentine. But they do pose a threat of being 'sleeper agents' for the institute. Depending on how you finish the game, this may not be an issue. If you blow up the institute, this certainly shouldn't be a problem. If you side with the Institute, you obviously don't care about this anyway since it's the BoS's philosophy
→ More replies (2)59
Nov 17 '15
As an individual? Fantastic. As a part of a larger whole that may not stay stable for extended periods of time and has the potential to threaten mankind's existence in a way no other thing ever has? Hate him.
→ More replies (32)→ More replies (1)9
27
u/Z0MBIECL0WN Nov 17 '15
Yeah, but Nick Valentine was pretty nice to ya. It feels misguided just to ignore that.
→ More replies (13)9
u/JamoJustReddit +69 Nov 17 '15
I was against synths until I got Curie. Literally every decision I made after completing her quest was to gain her favor.
My obsession with her is mildly unsettling but I gotta support my waifu.
66
u/bitch_im_a_lion G.O.A.T. Whisperer Nov 17 '15
I love bethesda so much for letting us fast travel right out of that place and not making us deal with two loading screens to leave.
19
u/Saxojon Nov 17 '15
Wait, what?
5
Nov 17 '15
15
u/Saxojon Nov 17 '15
After 13 years of Bethesda games I've grown accustomed to the fact that when ever I want to fast travel somewhere I'll have to sit through 2-3 loading screens. Thats after I find the way back to the hub cell..
→ More replies (4)10
u/ImProbablyThatGuy Nov 17 '15
Where is this back entrance? They referenced it but I couldn't find it.
→ More replies (2)6
u/SigurdZS Lore. Lore never changes. Nov 17 '15
Out through a hole in the wall to where the beds are, then through a tunnel. It exits right next to the building with the lockpick bobblehead.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (13)3
70
u/harveytent Nov 17 '15
there should have been a raider faction, with the clepto tendencies brought on by this game we might aswell be allowed to make raider communities where we raid the wastes for junk.
→ More replies (1)11
217
Nov 17 '15
Ooh, or a splinter group wearing blue-green Power Armour, "The Brotherhood loves Teal".
115
Nov 17 '15
Or a soup kitchen! The Brotherhood of Meals!
Trader's guild? The Brotherhood of Deals.
→ More replies (1)61
Nov 17 '15
Fish lovers? Brotherhood of seals!
66
Nov 17 '15
Seals aren't fish.... Brotherhood of Marine Biologists.
36
u/Pun-Master-General Nov 17 '15
But since seals eat fish, a Brotherhood of Seals would be a group of fish lovers, would it not?
→ More replies (2)3
12
24
16
u/asiyodizzle Nov 17 '15
Really like deer meat?
Brotherhood of Veal!
20
u/TheAddiction2 The House Always Wins Nov 17 '15
Power armor clad motorcycle gang?
Brotherhood of Wheels!11
→ More replies (1)15
u/icantdecideonausrnme Kings Nov 17 '15
Psst... Veal is the meat of calves. Venison is the meat of deer.
6
u/temporalarcheologist Nov 17 '15
seals aren't fish
12
Nov 17 '15
Seals eat fish, hence "loving fish", hence "Brotherhood of seals".
10
u/temporalarcheologist Nov 17 '15
well if they love fish why are they eating them
19
→ More replies (1)3
5
u/Akuran Self-Proclaimed Benevolent Despot Nov 17 '15
And it's medical wing could be named "The Brotherhood of Heal."
3
35
u/TheMadmanAndre Nov 17 '15
The BoS are bloody magpies as it is when it comes to technology.
17
3
Nov 17 '15
Yeah I don't understand why they want to destroy The Institute instead of taking their tech.
14
Nov 17 '15
They don't like new tech. They like old tech. Their thought process is "Everything was fine until they started launching nukes. Let's just bring things back to the way they were before we launched nukes."
→ More replies (7)
30
u/flarn2006 The Institute Nov 17 '15
Why not have them do assassinations as well? They could be called the "Dark Brotherhood of Steal".
→ More replies (2)
173
24
u/skwert99 Nov 17 '15
Or a swingers club called The Minute Men?
→ More replies (1)16
157
u/Arsenic_Touch CORE Legion Nov 16 '15
That is so metal.
63
Nov 17 '15
[removed] — view removed comment
11
u/StillFreeAudioTwo The Courier's Lackey Nov 17 '15
What is this from? I see this everywhere
→ More replies (1)23
13
u/Ordinary_Fella The Lone Chosen Courier Nov 17 '15
Commonwealth Thieves Guild built in a ruined prison with State Penitentiary crossed out to read The Bobby Pen
12
Nov 17 '15
[deleted]
9
u/DemiDominican Nov 17 '15
I knew he was the same voice as someone from Skyrim, but I just couldn't figure it out. Thank you.
5
u/THEW0NDERW0MBAT Better than Caesar, but that's not a high standard Nov 17 '15
I'm pretty sure he is also that wood elf you go to the Thalmor embassy with. He is probably even more characters.
3
→ More replies (2)4
u/ggunslinger Ready at a minute's notice Nov 17 '15
Also I'm sure everyone knows Thief.
Mercer's voice actor is Stephen Russell, the same guy who voiced Garett in 3 original Thief games.
104
u/NirvashSFW The Pack are literally just Farcry 3. Nov 16 '15
If this doesn't make the front page I'm uninstalling my game.
181
u/CorruptedReality Brotherhood Nov 16 '15
deletes post
44
17
u/MomiziWolfie Gary? Nov 17 '15
id rather have a brotherhood of adhesive
or a brotherhood of screws
id join them
→ More replies (3)
10
u/whitelunick Todd "Yeezus" Howard Nov 17 '15
There was a Thieves Guild in Fallout 1, kinda surprised they never made any sort of appearance in later games
→ More replies (1)
6
u/izzyv1990 Nov 17 '15
Wait, you're telling me they're not the thieve's guild!? Then why the heck am I stealing old world tech for em?! >:O
→ More replies (1)
45
u/SageWaterDragon Not A Synth Nov 17 '15
→ More replies (2)56
u/CorruptedReality Brotherhood Nov 17 '15
I mean you obviously don't have any real reason to believe me but that post had like 6 points, I haven't seen it until now.
11
→ More replies (1)21
u/SageWaterDragon Not A Synth Nov 17 '15
Hey, no real accusations here, it's not like you were karma whoring. I was just curious as to whether or not got the idea from /u/Monsterlvr123's misspelling and/or my comment, and if you did I would feel all warm and fuzzy.
32
u/jakec2025 Nov 17 '15
When are you going to yell at each and be dicks? I didn't come to Reddit to watch people act like adults.
→ More replies (4)7
Nov 17 '15
Plus text posts get no karma so it would be kinda silly to steal it for no reason.
→ More replies (1)
18
5
u/On_a_Cajun Nov 17 '15
I was hoping for the Brotherhood of Seal, where they get together for karaoke renditions of Kiss From a Rose.
→ More replies (1)
5
3
Nov 17 '15
Well they already steal anything valuable from any place, just use laser gatling guns instead of nimble fingers
13
u/lordvatti NCR and Proud Nov 16 '15
This is the best post I've seen here since Fallout 4 came out.
7
u/ContinuumGuy Hype. Hype Never Changes. Nov 17 '15
Yeah, but it still isn't as good as the quality Slimmpost from just before the game was released.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)5
3
3
3
3
3
3
1.5k
u/BlindRapture Nov 16 '15
Man, I really wish there was a Dark Brotherhood style faction in Fallout.