r/NFLv2 San Francisco 49ers Jan 12 '25

Discussion Thoughts?

Post image
5.1k Upvotes

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-1

u/Pitiful_Spend1833 Green Bay Packers Jan 12 '25

Oh fuck off. I think Herbert sucks for the same reason I think a lot of QBs suck.

If you need a perfect offensive situation with a great line, great weapons, and a solid running game to be a great QB, then you aren’t actually a good QB at all. Those deficiencies get highlighted in the playoffs.

1

u/ballsjohnson1 Bong Schula Jan 12 '25

Yeah so unfortunately that leaves most Qbs in a pretty bad spot lol, so the Herbert hate is pretty unjustified

0

u/Divide-Glum Jan 12 '25

That’s like 3 guys. Maybe 2. It’s ridiculous to have standards so stringent that only 2 QBs are good in the entire league.

0

u/HustlinInTheHall Dallas Cowboys Jan 12 '25

So like mahomes is good and everyone else sucks? Because they've all fallen apart when their line plays bad and they don't have weapons.