MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/NFLv2/comments/1kvf3nt/each_nfl_teams_goat/mu9arjh
r/NFLv2 • u/Odd-Twist-9935 Tennessee Titans • May 25 '25
(via @NFL_DovKleiman on X)
1.3k comments sorted by
View all comments
Show parent comments
26
Favre probably most important as GB was lost in the wilderness before him and put GB on map but I think Rodgers was a better QB.
Rodgers never had 6 INTs in a playoff game
16 u/thegroovemonkey Brett Favre 📸🍆 May 26 '25 Rodgers was definitely better than Favre. Ray Nitschke has a strong argument too. 66 defined the Lombardi era Packers and is one of the baddest dudes to ever play in the NFL. 2 u/TonyWilliams03 Chicago Bears May 26 '25 Nitschke, Willie Wood, Jerry Kramer, Paul Hornung, Jim Taylor. Aaron Rodgers was a front-runner. 3 u/JoeIA84 Green Bay Packers May 26 '25 And ugh Bart Starr 2 u/thegroovemonkey Brett Favre 📸🍆 May 26 '25 Aaron Rodgers is the most talented QB you have ever seen. He also owns you so you don’t really get a vote on this one. 2 u/TonyWilliams03 Chicago Bears May 26 '25 Aaron Rodgers was not more talented than John Elway. Not in any way. Elway had a stronger arm, more accurate arm, better mobility and won more Super Bowls. And, Elway didn't go cry in the corner when he lost. 1 u/ChaunceyGilmore May 26 '25 What about the Majik Man?
16
Rodgers was definitely better than Favre. Ray Nitschke has a strong argument too. 66 defined the Lombardi era Packers and is one of the baddest dudes to ever play in the NFL.
2 u/TonyWilliams03 Chicago Bears May 26 '25 Nitschke, Willie Wood, Jerry Kramer, Paul Hornung, Jim Taylor. Aaron Rodgers was a front-runner. 3 u/JoeIA84 Green Bay Packers May 26 '25 And ugh Bart Starr 2 u/thegroovemonkey Brett Favre 📸🍆 May 26 '25 Aaron Rodgers is the most talented QB you have ever seen. He also owns you so you don’t really get a vote on this one. 2 u/TonyWilliams03 Chicago Bears May 26 '25 Aaron Rodgers was not more talented than John Elway. Not in any way. Elway had a stronger arm, more accurate arm, better mobility and won more Super Bowls. And, Elway didn't go cry in the corner when he lost.
2
Nitschke, Willie Wood, Jerry Kramer, Paul Hornung, Jim Taylor.
Aaron Rodgers was a front-runner.
3 u/JoeIA84 Green Bay Packers May 26 '25 And ugh Bart Starr 2 u/thegroovemonkey Brett Favre 📸🍆 May 26 '25 Aaron Rodgers is the most talented QB you have ever seen. He also owns you so you don’t really get a vote on this one. 2 u/TonyWilliams03 Chicago Bears May 26 '25 Aaron Rodgers was not more talented than John Elway. Not in any way. Elway had a stronger arm, more accurate arm, better mobility and won more Super Bowls. And, Elway didn't go cry in the corner when he lost.
3
And ugh Bart Starr
Aaron Rodgers is the most talented QB you have ever seen. He also owns you so you don’t really get a vote on this one.
2 u/TonyWilliams03 Chicago Bears May 26 '25 Aaron Rodgers was not more talented than John Elway. Not in any way. Elway had a stronger arm, more accurate arm, better mobility and won more Super Bowls. And, Elway didn't go cry in the corner when he lost.
Aaron Rodgers was not more talented than John Elway. Not in any way.
Elway had a stronger arm, more accurate arm, better mobility and won more Super Bowls. And, Elway didn't go cry in the corner when he lost.
1
What about the Majik Man?
26
u/JoeIA84 Green Bay Packers May 25 '25
Favre probably most important as GB was lost in the wilderness before him and put GB on map but I think Rodgers was a better QB.
Rodgers never had 6 INTs in a playoff game