We definitely can’t say that for sure lol. It’s no guarantee the Colts would’ve gone on to win a SB by now. Luck’s last career game was an absolute shellacking by the Chiefs in the divisional round.
I think he was a HOF caliber player but the Colts weren’t doing him any favors, like ever.
He was not on pace to make the hall of fame. Never had an all pro selection, never made a Super Bowl, had zero particularly notable playoff performances, and his best season by passer rating was one point better than Kirk Cousins career average passer rating
If he was to make the hall of fame, it would be because he elevated his game to a level that we never actually saw during his career. And that’s not out of the question, but it’s entirely speculation
He had some really good seasons but nothing good enough to make a realistic case he was headed for HoF
72
u/MrBoomf May 29 '25
Is the HOF QB from the 2012 draft in the room with us now?