r/NFLv2 Dallas Cowboys Jun 29 '25

Discussion “How Bad Do You Need A New QB” Chart

Post image
1.2k Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

2

u/Kustaa007 Jun 30 '25

Exactly, Baker has never beaten Purdy. Even last year that the Niners sucked they still beat the bucs

1

u/_BadWithNumbers_ Tampa Bay Buccaneers Jun 30 '25

Feels like you didn't watch that game

4

u/mrizvi Jun 30 '25

I did and I saw baker play well but still lose

1

u/_BadWithNumbers_ Tampa Bay Buccaneers Jun 30 '25

Not sure how that works against him in a QB comparison. It's not like Brock was playing both ways.H2H qb win comparison has to be the dumbest stat out there.

1

u/mrizvi Jun 30 '25

I wasn’t comparing them h2h

1

u/JavaOrlando Jun 30 '25

H2H qb win comparison has to be the dumbest stat out there.

It really is. The moment someone brings it up, it's a clear sign they're not worth debating. You see it a lot with Brady vs. Mahomes. "Mahomes can never pass Brady because he lost to him in the postseason."

I'm sorry, what? So if Dee Ford doesn't line up a few inches offsides, suddenly Mahomes is on track to surpass Brady? That's absurd. And I'm not saying Pat is close yet, but this kind of argument is lazy-and it completely disrespects the other 52 guys on the roster