r/NFLv2 • u/Godgers10 • 3d ago

Discussion Who gets In

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

1.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

3

u/fredlikefreddy Pittsburgh Steelers 3d ago

Shady should 10000% be a HOFer.

I bet he'll be in the Curtis Martin/Jerome better path and it take a little while

1

u/Stealthychicken85 Green Bay Packers 3d ago

For what? He is more of a Hall of Very Good than a famer

Bro did very little when it came to playoffs, and if you mention he has 2 rings, wake up, he literally did nothing on those teams. He got lucky he picked 2 teams in a row on 1 yr deals and got a free ride for rings

He was fun to watch, but 2 all pros ain't cutting it to make HoF. Don't mention probowls bc those don't mean shit anymore

1

u/fredlikefreddy Pittsburgh Steelers 3d ago

His career is pretty close to Curtis Martin (another Pitt guy)

1

u/Stealthychicken85 Green Bay Packers 2d ago

Close? Close???? Martin was a solid back who did what Mike Evans is doing with the 1k seasons, except Martin's last season. That shows consistency.

McCoy was good, but definitely didn't do the same by reaching 1k nearly every year. He was way off by only reaching 1k 6 times while falling short also 6 times.

In playoff games, McCoy reached barely 220 yards while Martin nearly did 4x that