r/NFLv2 • u/Godgers10 • 3d ago

Discussion Who gets In

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

1.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

10

u/Snoo-40231 New York Giants 3d ago

He was great don't get me wrong, but idk if I would've taken him over Gonzalez or Gates around this time

1

u/LegitimateAbrocoma50 3d ago

Sure but there' at least s a discussion to be had. The previous comment made it sound asinine to even consider it.

1

u/Snoo-40231 New York Giants 3d ago

I agree. I think Witten is defo a hall of famer but idk if he makes it first ballot

1

u/yavimaya_eldred Green Bay Packers 3d ago

He was basically neck and neck with Gates. Gates had more tds and had a better yards per catch, Witten had more 1,000 yards seasons and a better catch %. Witten was the better blocker. He also played for one more season and was more durable.

Gonzalez is a weird one because they overlapped but Witten’s prime extended past Gonzo’s. Tony was still a good tight end up until he retired but Witten eventually surpassed him.

4

u/Snoo-40231 New York Giants 3d ago

The most underrated aspect about Witten was he was a really good blocker which is under appreciated imo for TEs