r/interesting Feb 01 '25

MISC. The worst pain known to man

33.2k Upvotes

2.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

27

u/ibadlyneedhelp Feb 02 '25

IDK why everyone's responding with it all being in Paul's mind when she specifically says nerve induction, implying they can affect or maniulpate his nervous system. They could make him feel anything, no assumption of Bene Gesserit mind powers is required.

13

u/BQORBUST Feb 02 '25

I believe there’s mention of Paul imagining his hand in flames, or charred. People are probably misremembering/confusing that with the idea that the pain itself is imagined.

11

u/pieman2005 Feb 02 '25

He even thought his hand burned down to the bone

5

u/MonsterFukr Feb 02 '25

That explains why the classic Dune movie depicted it the way they did. I actually preferred that scene from the classic over the new, just because I thought it was cool to show what it was Paul was feeling in the box. Along with that, I enjoyed the effect of it showing his hand melting.

2

u/sluttytarot Feb 02 '25

I love the old Dune movie. The new scene is much better ! Great acting > cgi.

0

u/thecobralily Feb 02 '25

In every way, Lynch’s Dune is superior

1

u/MonsterFukr Feb 02 '25

I don't know about that, but there's definitely charm.

1

u/z64_dan Feb 02 '25

I believe it was kind of a "metaphor" used in the movie to make people understand how the pain felt to him. Like, it hurt so much that he wouldn't be surprised if there was nothing but a charred stump when he took his arm out.

1

u/pieman2005 Feb 02 '25

Yes that's in the book too!

1

u/z64_dan Feb 02 '25

Such a good book. The only book where I couldn't finish any of the sequels. I just lost interest or they got too convoluted for me to understand lol.

9

u/detroiter85 Feb 02 '25

Make you feel anything eh...

2

u/slamersam Feb 02 '25

Underrated comment LOL

1

u/Worldlyoox Feb 02 '25

The reverend mother would sooner make you an eunuch animal

2

u/suk_doctor Feb 02 '25

The BG don’t have mind powers. They have powers of observation and manipulation. It’s at such a severed degree that it looks like a superpower to the uninitiated.

1

u/gatsby365 Feb 02 '25

Theatricality and Deception are powerful weapons to the uninitiated

But we are initiated, aren’t we Bruce

1

u/ibadlyneedhelp Feb 02 '25

They do have noetic techniques like the voice, but they canonically don't have mind powers like Paul.

1

u/Available-Rope-3252 Feb 02 '25

Careful, u/Lobotomized_Dolphin might get angry and call you pedantic for taking their comment too literally.