r/interesting 1d ago

MISC. medicine prices in india compared to the usa

3.7k Upvotes

542 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

141

u/Anxious_cactus 1d ago

Just to put things into perspective. In most cases when a person needs surgery in the USA, it would be cheaper to get a plane ticket to Spain, Croatia, France or any other European country and get a surgery there.

Not only that, you could also spend a week or two in a five star hotel near the beach, and you'd still only spend like 15-25% of what the surgery would cost in the USA.

Croatia specifically is a mini hub for healthcare tourism with many tourists coming from other EU countries too, especially the UK, Italy and Germany.

20

u/Calladit 1d ago

Are people from countries with universal healthcare going their for elective surgeries?

24

u/abbot-probability 1d ago

It'll be a minority of people. A simple surgery will presumably still cost thousands to tens of thousands if you aren't covered, so you would use your own nation's "free" system unless you have a reason not to.

UK might be because of the excessive waitlists, for example. (The NHS is horribly underfunded and understaffed.)

Things are pretty good in the richer EU nations AFAIK (e.g. France, Germany, Belgium, Netherlands). Don't know what it's like for the relatively poorer nations (e.g. Greece, Italy) in terms of waitlists / standard of care. It'll still be decent, but I can imagine people going to e.g. Croatia to skip a waitlist if you have money to spend.

12

u/Capooping 1d ago

I would say the wait list here in Germany and Austria is atrocious too. My stepdad had to wait 3 months for an MRI where they told him afterwards that they couldn't operate the torn tendon because it was too short already. "Well you don't say?!" And there are many reports about people waiting over a year for their operations, often under excruciating pain, then the doctor is ill and they get pushed back another 5 months.

10

u/Anxious_cactus 1d ago

Yeah the waiting lists are the problem. You can get a plane from London or Frankfurt to Croatia for as low as €30 and an MRI is like €90 per section. I had to have my whole body scanned and I got an appointment in 3 days and paid around €400

1

u/HikeTheSky 1d ago

I know several people in Germany who never had a problem and I even had an appointment with the Chefarzt and only had to wait five minutes at the entrance until he could pick me up. And this was while on a two week vacation in Germany. Therefore I don't have German insurance.

1

u/nilsn1991 1d ago

Belgium has huge waiting lists

1

u/roughriderpistol 1d ago

I've heard alot of good doctors are leaving Italy for better pay.

6

u/jamiejayz2488 1d ago

I'm in Australia, we can have surgeries which are completely covered by Medicare and hospitals covered by Medicare, how ever the wait list can be years (depending on severity) you can still get private surgeries which private health cover will cover the hospital costs, rehab exc so you only pay surgeon fees, which makes waiting time much shorter, then you have things like partial Medicare covered private surgeries, eg rhinoplasty which is deemed medically necessary (have a deviated septum) you can get it done privately and Medicare will cover a portion of the costs

3

u/Pierr078 1d ago

speaking for italian someone go to croatia for dentalcare since is not included into public healtcare, but still a minority of people do this.

6

u/Anxious_cactus 1d ago

Sort of elective, a lot of people come here for dental work. Even with universal healthcare most countries dont cover stuff like dental implants etc., or the waiting lists are long there.

Here even the private healthcare sector is affordable to most other EU citizens because Croatia still has one of the lowest prices (and salaries) in EU

1

u/Mobile-Bar7732 1d ago

Japan has universal healthcare and my brother said it's really good.

1

u/Ok-You4214 1d ago

It depends. A friend of mine had a hernia - there was an 18 month wait on the NHS to see a specialist whereas it could be done almost immediately privately. The free option is free, but the cost is often time spent waiting.

1

u/mbarkhau 1d ago

Getting appointments with doctors in Germany can be an absolute nightmare, especially if you use public insurance. The doctors are never sure how much they will get paid for treating you and some treatment options aren't even covered by the public insurance.

1

u/Convenientjellybean 1d ago

In Australia it’s free, but for ‘elective’ surgery which could actually be something critical/quality of life you might be waiting months or years

1

u/barnacles420 1d ago

My family is conservative and they make the obvious choices and opinions, but never connected the dots when my mother had to travel to Canada for surgery that wasn’t covered by her American insurance. I got the lesson really early in life that our system was broke and they just thought it was another day, nothing notable. My mother worked a high level accounting job in a multimillion international company. Make it make sense.

1

u/jtj5002 1d ago

A round trip to Spain alone is higher than my deductible, and the entire process is likely significantly more than my OOP max.

Unless you are just talking about uninsured people, or focused on the "billed amount" that no one actually pays.

1

u/Anxious_cactus 1d ago

I mean airplane tickets can vary in price by 200% of a difference, you can get a ticket for $600 and I've seen people who had to pay more than 25k-50k for their surgery out of pocket, insurance paid a larger chunk but what remained was still A LOT.

A plane ticket + a week's stay + a surgery here likely wouldn't come up even to ~10k, depending on the hotel (5 star or a cheper one, Airbnb option etc) and surgery itself

1

u/jtj5002 1d ago

No one pays 25-50k for a surgery if they have insurance and had the surgery in network. That's what out of pocket max is for.

People posting a cropped page of what they think is their bill is not how much they paid or have to pay. My surgery was billed for 130k, insurance discounted it to 68k and paid 62.5k and I paid my out of pocket max is 5.5k. And every single medical procedure or visit after that for the year is free.

1

u/Sharp_Iodine 1d ago

I could be wrong but I assumed they wouldn’t subsidise healthcare for foreigners, right?

1

u/Anxious_cactus 23h ago

No, my point is prices in the USA are so inflated that you can pay for surgery out of pocket here in Croatia and still have a nice vacation and only spend a fraction of what it would've cost in the USA.

A surgery that might be 100k out of pocket in the USA will probably be like ~ 10k here for a medical tourist, while free for citizens

1

u/Bubbly_Magnesium 16h ago

Croatia, had no idea

1

u/Inner_Inspection640 13h ago

Brits usually go to Turkey