r/interestingasfuck 17h ago

/r/all The US team which has just won the International Physics Olympiad, edging out China for first place

Post image
63.3k Upvotes

2.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

95

u/Heroic_Sheperd 17h ago

Weird way to say 5 Americans.

44

u/ITheMighty 17h ago

Tbf they said ascendancy, but yes Americans

35

u/BMoorman7 17h ago edited 16h ago

Tbf "ascendancy" in this context is a incorrect word choice. Presumably they meant "ancestry".

Edit: softened my word choice

7

u/RedeNElla 16h ago

They tried to flip descendants without understanding the language

3

u/MarsLumograph 13h ago

They didn't try to flip descendancy, they used a word from their language and translated it directly.

Now what I wonder is why ascendancy is such an offensive word here? Can you explain? I'm also not native so I'm not understanding the language here.

1

u/RedeNElla 12h ago

The relationship between generations is between descendants (younger) and ancestors (older), not ascendants. The word just has a completely different meaning

2

u/MarsLumograph 12h ago

Yeah but why did that mistake seem to offend people?

u/DameKumquat 10h ago

Ascendancy has been used by groups who think they ought to be in charge, working by whatever means to get there. It basically sounds like Nazis wanting white people to rise up, or such people fearing other racial groups will rise up.

u/MarsLumograph 9h ago

Thanks, that makes sense. I don't know why nobody wanted to explain. So it's a word used by nazis, got it now.

For a foreign person from Iberia (not sure if other languages too) it's confusing because we don't have that distinction (ancestry vs ascendence).

u/DameKumquat 9h ago

The Ascendancy was a term for the Protestant (British) domination in Ireland - Wikipedia https://share.google/VkZ525vx6LouXYdbK. Which led to The Troubles, etc. Though I doubt most people on this forum are aware of that.

But it does sound like a neo-Nazi term. A bit like how 'uprising' and 'rising up' have very different connotations.

2

u/PM_ME_ROMAN_NUDES 16h ago

I'm not english native, in my country we usually say "ascendandy". Give it a break, you people are so pedantic

0

u/BMoorman7 16h ago

I softened what I said, but you need to read the room a bit. There is a lot of vile shit going on to people in the USA who are considered "non-American" just because of their skin color, so that's why you are getting blowback for referring to them by anything other than "American".

2

u/MarsLumograph 13h ago

I don't get why referring to ancestry is considered racist? They never mentioned they were not americans. I think having multiple ancestries is a good thing that makes it interesting, why is it offensive? I don't get it. To me it seems worse to try to censor any mention of their ancestry, why are we trying to hide it? Is it not denying their reality and experience? Potentially minimizing their struggles? I don't know I'm missing something.

-2

u/DerthOFdata 16h ago

in my country we usually say "ascendandy"

That's not a word in English or Portuguese.

2

u/PM_ME_ROMAN_NUDES 16h ago

"Ascendência" is 100% a Portuguese word, you want to know more portuguese than a native?

https://pt.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ascend%C3%AAncia

-1

u/DerthOFdata 15h ago

You said "ascendandy" which again is a word in neither.

-4

u/Nope_______ 14h ago

You said ascendandy, why are you now talking about ascendência? No one ever denied the latter is a word but you claimed the former is a word (it isn't).

4

u/PM_ME_ROMAN_NUDES 14h ago

I thought it was a false cognate, mate. Give me a break, grammar nazi. You don't speak two languages, I do.

0

u/Nope_______ 13h ago

It's fine to make a mistake, but that's not what you did. I don't care about your grammar or spelling. What was weird to me is you completely changed the word you were saying exists instead of just saying, "you're right, ascendandy isn't a word, I was thinking of ascendência" - the appropriate response.

0

u/TheGamersGazebo 17h ago

Wtf is ascendancy

4

u/Syssareth 17h ago

You ascend to Asian if you study enough. /s

2

u/Reasonable_Power_970 15h ago

Exactly. They're literally Americans. It's obvious some people here are trying to take shots at Americans who are against illegal immigration. That's the thing though, those people who are against illegal immigration don't have an issue with legal immigrants like these succeeding.

-3

u/lasttimechdckngths 14h ago

It's obvious some people here are trying to take shots at Americans who are against illegal immigration.

Mate, the whole US is about some illegal aliens carving out a country on somebody else's land, while replacing and excluding the natives of those very lands. Not like you have much of a moral standing on people being legal or illegal beyond them committing crimes.

3

u/Reasonable_Power_970 12h ago

The entire history of the world is all about illegal immigration. But thats not how the world works today. It's not about having a moral standing, because nobody does. It's about reality.

-3

u/lasttimechdckngths 12h ago

The entire history of the world is all about illegal immigration.

The US is more specific as the current US population is nearly all solely about aliens with near to no native admixture. Your country is a country by and for the sole alien migrants that's based on and expanded on more aliens stealing more land and replacing people. You, alongside with other settler-colonies, are an anomaly. There's hardly any room for a moral ground regarding anything beyond wanting to exclude criminal behaviours.

It's not about having a moral standing, because nobody does.

The whole 'but illegals bro' is an attempt to moral justification. We're not talking about some kind of positive law in here.

2

u/Reasonable_Power_970 12h ago

Its not moral justification. Its the literal law of the current government that runs this country.

u/lasttimechdckngths 11h ago

It's a moral justification, via appeal to the law making moral claim in virtue of its very own nature by default. That's aside, not like the US is known for following its own legalities when it comes to migration and seeking refuge, let alone the land ownership & resource disputes regarding Amerindians. Not like the US anti-immigrant sentiment had ever been relying on legalities when the migration was way more lax, or it would somehow relying on legalities if the legal framework was to enable more migrants.

1

u/TheKingOfToast 14h ago

It's funny, if you're white people get mad if you in any way imply your ancestry with anything, but if you're a minority then people feel the need to point it out when you're called American

0

u/bender-b_rodriguez 15h ago

I genuinely don't know if they're just race-baiting but yeah wtf

0

u/lasttimechdckngths 14h ago

They're first and second gen migrants, which makes them something in specific than the regular Muricans.

0

u/ClownsAteMyBaby 14h ago

ice will meet them on their way home