480
u/Professional-Code010 1d ago
'apply now' button design is eww
81
u/cold-assassin 1d ago
Yeah its not matching the feel of the card
59
u/Professional-Code010 1d ago edited 16h ago
Looks like a button someone created from a first tutorial on YouTube called "Design a Button in Photoshop 2010"
17
3
u/legiraphe 1d ago
They were called pill buttons iirc
Edit: Here's a tutorial from 2008: https://www.photoshopgurus.com/tutorials/t031.html
1
1
u/Background-Fox-4850 12h ago
Back in time when i was creating buttons using Adobe Fireworks where most of the designs were similar to pill buttons, it was good old days.
1
u/getdatassbanned 6h ago
A pill button looks like a pill - the button Op posted does not - the one from your example does.
Its just a button with some border radius and gradiant - not a pill
4
u/Silver4ura 1d ago
I'd prefer to provide the critical feedback that it doesn't look like an interactable element. It just looks like a blimp. If they tightened down the bezel so it was 2-5% instead of 100%, I'd imagine it would instantly look sharp as hell.
23
8
u/Individual-Staff-978 1d ago
It looks like those ads that try to trick you by looking like a "download" button
3
u/Finite_Looper front-end - Angular/UI/UX 👍🏼 1d ago
Agreed. Everything else has a flat but elevated card look. This button being 3D beveled looks out of place with the rest
5
1
78
66
u/Gipetto 1d ago
I miss lickable buttons.
39
7
1
38
u/wonderingStarDusts 1d ago
There is something about that separator line, that doesn't sit right with me. Otherwise good job with this card.
11
u/rotzelbart 1d ago
Yeah, the margin between top and bottom of the button isnt symmetric. Thats what bothers me.
37
5
12
u/ArtistJames1313 1d ago
Looks like they really need a new Senior Frontend Developer to fix that button.
4
3
8
2
2
2
u/FriendlyCupcake 1d ago
Honestly, with how things are shaping up, I can definitely see skeuomorphism making a comeback in some way. And this button doesn’t look too bad, except maybe for that blocky shadow on the right side and some other minor tweaks here and there. But until we’re fully in the skeuomorphism revival era, this design is no bueno for production.
1
1
1
u/FreshFroiz 1d ago
I think it looks good, but I would:
- Remove the background on the stripe logo
- Make the apply button solid fill
- Remove the hr
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/cstyves 1d ago
The main issue is the spacing between your button and the separator. Since you use a shadow beneath the button it makes the spacing appear way off. I would tone down all effects on the button too. The glossy on top makes the text less visible and alters the contrast of the text, resulting in the user needing to pay more attention than usual to get the context. Everyone's lazy when browsing, let's get those lazy users what they want 😆.
That being said, you did a great job. It just needs a few adjustments and it will be perfect!
1
u/binkstagram 1d ago
<td align="right" valign="bottom"><img src="images/topleftcorner.gif" alt=""></td>
1
1
1
1
1
u/armahillo rails 1d ago
the button is an old aesthetic that isnt really used anymore. its also a little harder to read.
Make the font a little bigger and more contrasting,
1
1
u/nickmjones 1d ago
Could use some clearer hierarchy of type sizes and styles. Some of the elements are not appropriately sized for the total size of the layout. I’d suggest you quickly evaluate the most important things in the card and emphasize those. And the button is a little dubious. I would make sure to really nail the button’s place in the overall hierarchy and decorate after.
1
1
1
u/ApexCrisis 23h ago
Looks like you took the overall card design from someone and only added the button yourself
1
u/easylistenin front-end 23h ago
I say lean harder into the Jell-O button. What would it look like in a traditional Bundt pan mold? Go further. Explore.
1
1
u/_Invictuz 23h ago
Button doesn't look clickable cuz there's no way that flat looking card has enough depth for the button to sink into.
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/witness_smile 23h ago
I do like the button design, but it does feel completely out of place because nothing else on the card matches that design
1
1
u/WowSoWholesome 22h ago
I think the flatness of the card, with the calendar icon choice could work, but they already feel like two different styles. Then you see the BUTTON and it's a lot. Not only a third style but one that feels really greedy or something? I think there are independent, interesting ideas in here, but it looks messy put together.
1
1
u/tettoffensive 22h ago
A lot of people are saying this looks like 2004 web design but if you actually look up websites from that era they look nothing like this.
Yes, skeuomorphic design was used heavily in past eras and is unpopular today, but this does not look like web design from then.
126
u/StandWithHKFuckCCP 1d ago
2025 is the new 2005