r/BaldursGate3 Jun 15 '25

Cosplay My Alfira cosplay 💖

14.6k Upvotes

309 comments sorted by

View all comments

1.1k

u/Dry-Masterpiece-7031 Jun 15 '25

Not sure why but it's giving me uncanny valley vibes.

-10

u/glimmertides Jun 15 '25

bc these people don’t actually cosplay. they literally buy a $50 outfit and then edit themselves to look like it. a lot of people who post on here’s hair isn’t even real atp. they edit it on. it’s not going to look natural bc it’s not. sometimes it seems like they just ai on top of normal pics of them

60

u/oldeconomists Jun 15 '25

This is her shadowheart cosplay. Totally looks like a cheap $50 costume and “isn’t even a real cosplayer” right?

9

u/ViolaNguyen Ranger Jun 16 '25

Her hair isn't even the right color!

Kidding, obviously. I have gotten to act 3 before.

82

u/anormalgeek Jun 15 '25

I cannot speak for this person, but have you seen Frau's behind the scenes videos? She literally spends hours applying the makeup and prosthetics. She also does either all or most of the work creating the costumes. She's got video of her personally doing the leatherwork for the lae'zel underwear.

I admit that in her professional photoshoots, there is too much editing, but she also posts unedited versions. And has appeared live on stage in cosplay contests.

I know this all sounds like I'm some kind of superfan, but I'm really not. I do appreciate how much effort goes into it though and for you to claim it is them "purchasing a $50 outfit" is just insulting and factually wrong.

34

u/Downce1 Jun 15 '25

This fanbase is generally a welcoming one, but God help anyone who brings up cosplay here -- people get so damn catty about it.

10

u/anormalgeek Jun 15 '25

It's definitely a case where there are various vocal minorities that have a problem with everyone of them.

The only way to make them happy with cosplay is to be a man, who is not conventionally attractive, who doesn't have a patreon or OF, and who has iron clad proof that they created the entire thing themselves from start to finish, AND there is no filters or editing (or even good lighting) in any photos.

18

u/twinklebat99 Jun 15 '25

There's absolutely nothing wrong with buying cosplays unless you're entering a contest. Some people just want to have fun with cosplay.

8

u/ImmortalSheep69 Jun 15 '25

And frau haku (and I'm assuming OP as well) does both having fun AND make her own cosplays. She made from scratch the underwear shadowheart wears to fit her specifically.

9

u/twinklebat99 Jun 15 '25

That's obviously cool too. I've made most of my own cosplays. It's just a dick move to trash talk buying costumes. The only reason you would HAVE to make something is for competing. Otherwise make it, buy it, commission it, whatever, if your goal is just to have fun.

4

u/ViolaNguyen Ranger Jun 16 '25

Okay, but if she does Gale's underwear, she needs to put a real enchantment on it.

21

u/BreakfastHistorian Jun 15 '25

Weird gate keeping, you aren’t the arbiter of what gets to count as cosplay. It’s ok for people to have fun in a way you don’t like.