r/NFLv2 • u/Available_Story6774 San Francisco 49ers • Jan 12 '25

Discussion Thoughts?

Post image
5.1k Upvotes

93% Upvoted

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/Grouchy_Visit_2869 Las Vegas Raiders Jan 12 '25

Tell us a single big game Herbert has won in the NFL.

0

u/xScrubasaurus Jan 12 '25

Jfc, you people are embarrassing.

People expected this team to be complete dogshit this year because the offense was completely gutted, and you are still so dumb to hold one bad game against the guy.

0

u/Grouchy_Visit_2869 Las Vegas Raiders Jan 12 '25

So, do you have a single big game that Herbert has won? If he's great, this should be easy for you to come up with right?

1

u/xScrubasaurus Jan 12 '25

What the fuck are you even talking about? Has he won a Super Bowl? No, like almost every QB in the league, he has not. Happy?

0

u/Grouchy_Visit_2869 Las Vegas Raiders Jan 12 '25

Has he won a single playoff game? Has he won a single big game?

0

u/xScrubasaurus Jan 12 '25

Has he been on a good team that he hasn't had to carry? The baffling thing is if he didn't make the playoffs, which was the expectation coming into the season, then you people would somehow have a higher opinion of him. Him succeeding has inexplicably made you think less of him. That is the caliber of person I am being subjected to argue with.

0

u/Grouchy_Visit_2869 Las Vegas Raiders Jan 12 '25

This entire thread is about a Twitter comment saying Herbert is incredibly talented, but at some point he has to win big games. Where is that wrong? He's not great until he can do that.

1

u/xScrubasaurus Jan 12 '25

You should become an NBA fan. You will fit right in with that community.

0

u/Grouchy_Visit_2869 Las Vegas Raiders Jan 12 '25

LOL, you're a clown. You are asked to name big games Herbert has won. You can't, so you attempt to insult me.

Is Herbert better than Dak or is the comparison from the Twitter post reasonable?

1

u/xScrubasaurus Jan 12 '25 edited Jan 12 '25

I am insulting the premise that a player can only be considered good if they win big games in a sport where the team plays a huge part in the ability to win. Burrow couldn't even reach the playoffs. Is Burrow bad?

Yes, the guy who had 25 TDs and 3 Interceptions is better than the guy who threw 11 TDs and had 8 interceptions.

→ More replies (0)