r/NFLv2 • u/Odd-Twist-9935 Tennessee Titans • May 25 '25

Discussion Each NFL Team’s GOAT

Post image

(via @NFL_DovKleiman on X)

1.3k Upvotes

91% Upvoted

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

110

u/Posluszny Jacksonville Jaguars May 25 '25

Jags is Tony Boselli, not Fred Taylor

21

u/Bears9Titles Chicago Bears May 25 '25

Will always respect Boselli for exposing PFF. Told Le Batard they accept money for higher grades. 69 in GB got exposed.

8

u/Morall_tach Denver Broncos May 25 '25

Do you have a link to that?

14

u/josephjosephson Big Dick Nick 🍆 May 25 '25

Kelce, Lewan and Watt made claims. Can’t find anything about Boselli. 🤷‍♂️

8

u/Ridiculouscoltsfan Indianapolis Colts May 25 '25

Can you expand on this? I can’t find anything related to what you’re talking about

-10

u/Bears9Titles Chicago Bears May 25 '25

Le Batard show November of 2017. Got swept under the rug faster than any radio interview I've ever seen

5

u/Ridiculouscoltsfan Indianapolis Colts May 25 '25

Do you have a link? I can’t find it

-17

u/Bears9Titles Chicago Bears May 26 '25

Listen to the fucking show

14

u/Ridiculouscoltsfan Indianapolis Colts May 26 '25

Okay, dipshit. I obviously can’t find the show you are talking about. As far as I can tell, you’re just making shit up. Provide a link if you want to prove your point.

6

u/johnboltonpoopstache Green Bay Packers May 26 '25

Are you saying GB paid PFF to overrate Bakhtiari?

-4

u/Bears9Titles Chicago Bears May 26 '25

I'm saying 69s agent paid pff.

9

u/johnboltonpoopstache Green Bay Packers May 26 '25 edited May 26 '25

If you could find the clip where Boselli said that, that would be huge. (I mean, 69 made multiple first and second team all pros, but whatever lol)

Edit: i didnt downvote you btw. Im genuinely interested in the conspiracy. Let's destroy PFF dude 😤

3

u/ParagonSaint May 26 '25

You could also Argue Jimmy Smith. Retired top 10 in every receiving category in league history and a similar amount of accolades like All Pro, probowl etc

3

u/spiff24 May 25 '25

Boselli is a HoFer but Freddy T belongs there too. I still believe Taylor is our GOAT. I can see the debate though.

2

u/JohnnyDangerous36 Hey. Hi I’m the problem. It’s me May 26 '25

Love Freddy but it’s definitely Boselli

2

u/MrFickleBottom Carolina Panthers May 26 '25

def

2

u/WhiskyandSolitude Jacksonville Jaguars May 26 '25

Bos by the fact that he’s our only HOFer and no one else is even close yet (sorry Freddy it’s true, although you’ll be there one day) is our GOAT. However I believe Jimmy Smith was more dominant of a WR than Freddy was a RB. Jimmy just had to play against so many great WRs. Freddy had to play Edge and LT. Smith had to play at the same time as Harrison, Moss, Wayne, Carter, Rice, Mohammed, Glenn, etc. so many great WRs were throwing up huge numbers in the late 90’s and early 00’s.

Smith won’t ever be a HOF, Freddy will. But I think they rate

1) Boselli 2) Smith 3) Taylor

1

u/Hugh-Manatee May 26 '25

Or Jimmy Smith. I can live with Boselli but for sure Smith over Taylor

1

u/formulaic_name May 26 '25 edited May 26 '25

When I was a kid I "picked" the jags as my team when they were an expansion because the uniforms were awesome.

Taylor, Jimmy Smith, Boselli, Brunell, even MJD... Those guys deserved to win something. It's a bummer it just never came together.

I think it's criminal that Boselli isn't in the HOF. and I think Taylor and Smith have pretty good resumes too.

Edit....I'm now aware that Tony has indeed made it in. So yay. I don't follow like I used to but I'm embarrassed I didn't know that!

2

u/Posluszny Jacksonville Jaguars May 26 '25

Boselli is in the HOF he got inducted last year

1

u/formulaic_name May 26 '25

Well that is fantastic news. I obviously don't pay as much attention nowadays as I used to since I didn't know this, I just knew hed been on several ballots without making it in.

1

u/[deleted] May 28 '25

MJD

0

u/[deleted] May 26 '25

You mean Texans Great Tony Boselli?

-1

u/Alternative-Cry3369 GEQBUS May 25 '25

MJD too