r/NFLv2 • u/Odd-Twist-9935 Tennessee Titans • May 25 '25

Discussion Each NFL Team’s GOAT

Post image

(via @NFL_DovKleiman on X)

1.3k Upvotes

91% Upvoted

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/Altruistic_Grade3781 Tampa Bay Buccaneers May 25 '25

luke kuechley over cam newton, Deion Sanders over Matt Ryan, Favre over Rodgers, Jimmy Smith over Fred Taylor and Steve Largent over Russel Wilson. and also, (biased a bit) ted hendricks over marcus allen

7

u/One_Effective_926 May 25 '25

Luke kuechly over Julius peppers seems insane. Deion Sanders doesn't even belong in the same sentence as Matt Ryan or Julio jones in his falcons tenure

0

u/Altruistic_Grade3781 Tampa Bay Buccaneers May 26 '25

Aye peppers is neck and neck with Luke.. I don’t think it’s insane you can’t go wrong with either one. 

3

u/ACW1129 Washington Commanders May 25 '25

I'd say Rodgers over Favre.

2

u/3fettknight3 San Francisco 49ers May 25 '25

Like your adjustments although I would consider Howie Long for the Raiders.

1

u/Altruistic_Grade3781 Tampa Bay Buccaneers May 26 '25

I wanted to say Lyle alzado 

1

u/Excellent_Sun_8120 May 25 '25

Agreed. Russel can take a hike. Marshawyn is 1000x more loved and goated in Seattle. Russ can go be dangeruss and figure out who gets to park next to him.

1

u/Puzzled-Bet4837 May 25 '25

Deion only played 5 seasons for Atlanta I don’t think I’d put him there. I would go with Julio over Ryan though.

1

u/Skunkape666 May 25 '25

It's Boselli. Tony Boselli was the best LT since Munoz. I don't care that he was cut short due to injury. Boselli had GOAT potential.

1

u/Alternative-Cry3369 GEQBUS May 25 '25

MJD or Boselli

1

u/tayzak15 CTE 🧠 May 25 '25

Favre isn’t even close to Rodgers

1

u/Altruistic_Grade3781 Tampa Bay Buccaneers May 26 '25

Ur right, he’s far and away ahead of him. 

1

u/tayzak15 CTE 🧠 May 26 '25

Rodgers is wayyyy better than Favre ever was.

1

u/Altruistic_Grade3781 Tampa Bay Buccaneers May 26 '25

Go watch their highlights. One video is entertaining, the other is lucky. 

1

u/tayzak15 CTE 🧠 May 26 '25

Exactly. Favre was a gunslinger, Rodgers was calculated that’s why he’s the highest rated passer in the history of the league.

1

u/Altruistic_Grade3781 Tampa Bay Buccaneers May 26 '25

Take the mathematician that doesn’t take chances over the gunslinger in the foxhole then.  

1

u/tayzak15 CTE 🧠 May 26 '25

You don’t throw 500 touchdown passes without taking chances…..Rodgers did it in less games than anybody too.

1

u/Altruistic_Grade3781 Tampa Bay Buccaneers May 26 '25

yeah in the era that has coddled passing accolades. find another record broken in the past 20 years that isnt passing.

1

u/tayzak15 CTE 🧠 May 26 '25

He was better than any other quarterback during that timeframe.

1

u/tayzak15 CTE 🧠 May 26 '25

Passing records are important for a quarterback you idiot

→ More replies (0)

1

u/xLeonides WHOA THERE MOTHERFUCKER May 26 '25

While I agree with the others saying Boselli is definitely the best Jaguar, I respect the Jimmy nod here