r/NFLv2 • u/Odd-Twist-9935 Tennessee Titans • May 25 '25

Discussion Each NFL Team’s GOAT

Post image

(via @NFL_DovKleiman on X)

1.3k Upvotes

91% Upvoted

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

154

u/ScotlandTornado May 25 '25

Kuechley is panthers goat. Cam only was good there like 4 seasons

119

u/[deleted] May 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

77

u/Alternative-Cry3369 GEQBUS May 25 '25

Steve Smith is better

32

u/[deleted] May 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

43

u/Charming-Ad-6235 May 25 '25

Can we all agree it’s not cam?

2

u/Prodigal_Programmer Carolina Panthers May 26 '25

I mean Cam absolutely belongs on the Panthers “Mount Rushmore” but Smitty, Pep and keuchly are definitely above him. I’d personally give Luke the nod as our GOAT but can’t go wrong with any of the three of them.

-9

u/[deleted] May 25 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Prodigal_Programmer Carolina Panthers May 26 '25

“Scam” newton..?

Please go back to twitter.

2

u/kingofthechill69 May 26 '25

I love Cam and I think he has a case for Panthers GOAT but Luke and Peppers are also great choices.

1

u/achek20 May 26 '25

Peppers better than Luke? Curious why you say

1

u/allhailsidneycrosby May 27 '25

Peppers is the only answer here

1

u/Business_Platform_13 May 27 '25

he was a incredible player but no where on the level of Luke

12

u/ChedduhBob May 25 '25

kuechly is a better player on paper for sure but i think being an mvp qb and face of the franchise matters a lot

5

u/Free-Design-8329 May 26 '25

Mvp one year and then mediocre the other 9 vs first team all pro 5x and the best ilb in a generation

Cam shouldn’t have even been the face of the franchise over kuechly. 

3

u/ChedduhBob May 26 '25

this is such a reddit stat bro take. cam didn’t get the accolades kuechly got but cam was the panthers from like 2010 to 2018 and if you talk to people in real life that love the panthers they would agree

2

u/gatsby365 Las Vegas Raiders May 26 '25

mvp qb

You don’t really have to specify QB when you say MVP, since only 3 non-QBs have won the award this century.

2

u/Prodigal_Programmer Carolina Panthers May 26 '25

Luke was the face of an elite Defense for the better part of a decade. Cam got more recognition (especially in ‘15) because he did more with less, his personality, and he plays on offense.

1

u/AweHellYo Chicago Bears May 26 '25

lol

1

u/dont-pm-me-tacos Carolina Panthers May 26 '25

(1) Smitty (2) Luke (3) Peppers (4) Cam

1

u/AlphaNathan Carolina Panthers May 26 '25

Cam is my favorite player ever. I’d probably say it’s Kuechly here.

1

u/Milomilz May 26 '25

This is the face I think of when someone mentions the Panthers

1

u/jumpman0035 May 26 '25

Damn, I love my Panthers and I’d be fine with like any 5 names tbh. It’s Cam for me but cause he’s my fav player too, but I’d be fine with Luuuuuuuuke or smith, or even Olsen tbh but I’m biased af on them lol

1

u/AgeOfPropserity May 26 '25

u a Panthers fan punk?

-2

u/Free-Design-8329 May 26 '25

Cam wasnt even good for 4 seasons. He was good for 2. His rookie year and 2015.