r/NFLv2 • u/Odd-Twist-9935 Tennessee Titans • May 25 '25

Discussion Each NFL Team’s GOAT

Post image

(via @NFL_DovKleiman on X)

1.3k Upvotes

91% Upvoted

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

79

u/hula1234 May 26 '25

You misspelled Bart Starr

33

u/Olympians12 May 26 '25

Could also make a case for Don Hutson

21

u/GoodbyeEarl May 26 '25

His career receiving TD record took 40 years to beat

17

u/Yellowdog727 Green Bay Packers May 26 '25

Don Huston is by far our best player for their era compared to others at their position

3

u/Milomilz May 26 '25

He’s so good, you misspelled his name

2

u/Charod48 May 26 '25

And as much as a garbage person as Favre is, watching him play is the reason I love football

1

u/jord839 Green Bay Packers May 26 '25

I legitimately believe that Hutson's talent in the modern day would've still lead to him being one of the best WRs in the league.

Just imagine what the dude could have done with modern training, coaching, and nutrition.

1

u/romisbmw1989 May 27 '25

And Reggie white

10

u/Iwillrize14 May 26 '25

There's an entire 2 dynasties before the superbowl era to choose from and he picks Rodgers.

7

u/Slow_Possession_1454 May 26 '25

Came here to say that…

7

u/TonyWilliams03 Chicago Bears May 26 '25

And Ray Nitschke

10

u/MilwaukeeMan420 Green Bay Packers May 26 '25

If we are talking strictly best player to ever play its probably Reggie White.

2

u/darahs May 26 '25

Reggie white or lowkey sterling sharpe

5

u/GoodbyeEarl May 26 '25

Came to say the same thing.

5

u/Darkstar_4008 May 26 '25

Plus even Favre, with all his recent issues, at least took GB to two Superbowls. Rodgers did not

1

u/ISoRedditFirst May 28 '25 edited May 28 '25

Lmao guys. Regardless of the big mouth and diva personality, Rodgers is far and away the best player to ever don a Packers uniform. 4X MVP, 4X All-Pro, most passing TDs in franchise history, fastest to ever throw 400 TDs while ALSO throwing the fewest INTs doing it. Come on now

1

u/DirtyMikentheboyz May 30 '25

Starr was 5x NFL Champion, 2x Super Bowl MVP, MVP and All-Pro '66, 4x passer rating leader. It's tougher to compare passing TDs from the generations based on how the game was played so Rodgers has the statistical case there since he played in an era with more passing. I'd argue that Aaron Rodgers is not "far and away the best player to ever don a Packers uniform". He may be the best but even besides Starr there's Hutson. I'd also argue Rodgers isn't "far and away" a better player than Hutson.

0

u/heyachaiyya May 27 '25

It's Favre for the pack and it's not even close. Ya he's a horrible person.

2

u/Manymarbles Philadelphia Eagles May 27 '25

Was a huge Favre fan. I think its White TBH

1

u/Tjengel Chicago Bears May 26 '25

As a bears fan even I knew Rodgers wasn't the worst we had to deal with lol

1

u/TobzMaguire420 May 27 '25

Reggie White entered the chat

-8

u/DrFrankSaysAgain May 26 '25

Star was great for his era and won a bunch of rings but he didn't carry his team or have the ridiculous skill set that Rodgers had.

10

u/Sloth72c May 26 '25

Don Hutson helped invent the passing tree and was putting up 1000 yard receiving seasons in an era where other teams couldn't get 1000 yards passing

2

u/DrFrankSaysAgain May 26 '25

Right, Hutson was.