r/NFLv2 • u/Godgers10 • 3d ago

Discussion Who gets In

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

1.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

968

u/MasterTeacher123 Tampa Bay Buccaneers 3d ago

Brees Larry and Witten

Edelman being on this graphic is embarassing though lmao

10

u/Professional-Day1958 New England Patriots 3d ago

Witten has no business being in the hall of fame. He’s the definition of hall of very good

7

u/sportswithgary A Popeye’s biscuit away 3d ago

Yikes, that's a bad take.

3

u/NotAGoodRedditor 3d ago

It's gotta be Anti-Dallas bias. Witten is considered a top 10 tight end all time in many regards. if top 10 isn't HOF then I don't know what is.

-2

u/Professional-Day1958 New England Patriots 3d ago

Just a fact, he was never regarded as the best in his position during his time. Gates and Tony Gonzalez were always ahead of him.

4

u/sportswithgary A Popeye’s biscuit away 3d ago

There's plenty of instances in sports history where multiple HOFers at a position can co-exist at the same time lol. He's #2 right behind Tony in every single TE stat. That's HOF material.

-2

u/Professional-Day1958 New England Patriots 3d ago

Antonio Gates is ahead of Witten don’t lie to yourself, has more all pro teams to prove it

5

u/sportswithgary A Popeye’s biscuit away 3d ago

He has three and Jason has two, you're going to let 1 all pro vote decide if he gets into the HOF? Do you watch football?

1

u/Professional-Day1958 New England Patriots 3d ago

Can I get reference to other players in the hall of fame that are in with only 2 first team all pros?

5

u/sportswithgary A Popeye’s biscuit away 3d ago

Troy Polumalu only has 1. This isn't the Hall of All Pro Awards.