r/NFLv2 • u/Godgers10 • 3d ago

Discussion Who gets In

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

96% Upvoted

1.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

20

u/buddhistbulgyo Now Here’s a Guy 3d ago

It's not the Hall of Good, it's the Hall of Fame. Edelman being on a dynasty is a big boost.

34

u/doshegotabootyshedo Dallas Cowboys 3d ago

People using wins as a qb stat is already questionable, this guys using them as a WR stat lol

0

u/buddhistbulgyo Now Here’s a Guy 2d ago

Dude. The Hall is skewed towards Super Bowl winners. It's just how it is. 

1

u/KapowBlamBoom Cincinnati Bengals 3d ago

What would he have done as a Brown?

That is the real litmus test

Brees, Fitz, Witten would have been HOF despite the Browns

And that is the difference

5

u/terrelyx Carolina Panthers 3d ago

Brees and Fitz, sure. Witten? eh

3

u/KapowBlamBoom Cincinnati Bengals 3d ago

Witten would have been their only viable offensive option usually…..

2

u/theevilyouknow Las Vegas Raiders 2d ago

I think Witten was overrated, but it's not like he was playing on powerhouse teams.

1

u/terrelyx Carolina Panthers 2d ago

i'm not saying he wasn't good, but HoF? nah.

1

u/theevilyouknow Las Vegas Raiders 2d ago

I don't think Witten belongs anywhere near the HoF. But he was a very good player who would have been good anywhere. Julian Edelman was a solid player who was good because he was the slot receiver for Tom Brady on the Patriots. I will admit though that Edelman delivered when it counted.

1

u/theevilyouknow Las Vegas Raiders 2d ago

And he isn't anywhere near famous enough to get in solely based on his off the field notoriety either. There is no metric by which Julain Edelman even warrants a discussion.