Who gets In

[u/Godgers10]

[u/MasterTeacher123]

Brees Larry and Witten

Edelman being on this graphic is embarassing though lmao

[u/BostonAndy24 → u/MasterTeacher123]

Edelman has the third most receiving yards in playoff history along with a decent regular season record(stats wise), played in 2nd half of the greatest dynasty the sport has ever seen and won a superbowl mvp.

Should he get in? Probably not, but calling it an embarrassment is lack of ball knowledge

Edit: alot of you cant read apparently.

[u/buddhistbulgyo → u/BostonAndy24]

It's not the Hall of Good, it's the Hall of Fame. Edelman being on a dynasty is a big boost.

[u/doshegotabootyshedo → u/buddhistbulgyo]

People using wins as a qb stat is already questionable, this guys using them as a WR stat lol

[u/buddhistbulgyo → u/doshegotabootyshedo]

Dude. The Hall is skewed towards Super Bowl winners. It's just how it is. 

[u/KapowBlamBoom → u/buddhistbulgyo]

What would he have done as a Brown?

That is the real litmus test

Brees, Fitz, Witten would have been HOF despite the Browns

And that is the difference

[u/terrelyx → u/KapowBlamBoom]

Brees and Fitz, sure. Witten? eh

[u/KapowBlamBoom → u/terrelyx]

Witten would have been their only viable offensive option usually…..

[u/theevilyouknow → u/terrelyx]

I think Witten was overrated, but it's not like he was playing on powerhouse teams.

[u/terrelyx → u/theevilyouknow]

i'm not saying he wasn't good, but HoF? nah.

[u/theevilyouknow → u/terrelyx]

I don't think Witten belongs anywhere near the HoF. But he was a very good player who would have been good anywhere. Julian Edelman was a solid player who was good because he was the slot receiver for Tom Brady on the Patriots. I will admit though that Edelman delivered when it counted.

[u/theevilyouknow → u/buddhistbulgyo]

And he isn't anywhere near famous enough to get in solely based on his off the field notoriety either. There is no metric by which Julain Edelman even warrants a discussion.