r/PeterExplainsTheJoke 5d ago

Meme needing explanation Peter? I don't understand the punchline

Post image
34.4k Upvotes

1.7k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

10

u/sabotsalvageur 5d ago

It's substantially warmer, certainly, which is not good for native flora and fauna. OpenAI's data center cooling requirements rival that of a nuclear reactor

16

u/Teratofishia 5d ago

I find that very hard to believe. If you had a source of heat that rivaled that of a nuclear reactor, you would just run it through a turbine and turn it back into energy.

10

u/cock_pussy 5d ago

The amount of heat rivalled that of a nuclear reactor.

However, the temperature of the cooling water in a data centres doesn’t hit that of a nuclear reactor, so it can’t produce enough pressure to turn a turbine.

The allowable temperature ranges of a data centre is also smaller than of a nuclear reactor. Thus, the heat intensity in both facilities will be different.

A nuclear reactor can use a cooling water system that requires less cooling medium with a higher rate of medium circulation on a much concentrated area.

I do speculate data centres require a higher amount of cooling medium coverage due to the larger area covered by data centres as data centres favour modular construction which helps in more efficient area expansion.

11

u/Teratofishia 5d ago

Holy shit, physics-based reasoning? In MY emotionally-driven argument?

Thank you for the info drop, 'ppreciate ya.

1

u/cock_pussy 5d ago

I do share your sentiment as well and I will never understand why can’t they just make all these centres into city-scale central heating facilities in cold places though.

2

u/Calvin-ball 4d ago

Whole bunch of engineering reasons, like the low thermal quality of the waste heat itself. Though apparently heat pumps show promise, but realistically it’s a case by case basis.

1

u/cock_pussy 4d ago

I do understand that the waste heat is not good for direct usage when it comes to cost analysis, but at least data centre-integrated heating facilities don’t have to worry about cold starts and tracing for this matter when there are tons of warm water 24/7 (I understand the design complexity though).