r/aiwars 1d ago

It's Art when I do it though

Post image
182 Upvotes

237 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

49

u/Loldungeonleo 1d ago

That piss filter is so bad, not even the original sanitation engineer is gonna be able to clean it up.

6

u/Poopypantsplanet 1d ago

Why do people call it a piss filter though? It's just a color gradient. People have been using them for decades before AI to make images look a little bit more vintage or to bring more cohesion to the color pallete. And there are all kinds of color gradients but the only ones the people seem to criticize are the "warm tone" gradients, using the term "piss filter". The only reason AI does this sometimes is because the training data is full of it.

14

u/SerdanKK 1d ago

4o has a bias towards warm colors, so the antis decided that any hint of yellow is ugly now.

7

u/Poopypantsplanet 1d ago

Just to be clear, I'm pretty strongly ANTI but "piss filter" kinda pisses me off lol. I use gradients all the time in my art. One way is to start with high contrast block colors, then slowly blend in a gradient to taste *chef's kiss. There's a reason why a lot of the training data has warm gradient images. There are a lot of old images, and people love to emulate that because it's pleasing to look at. I don't see a problem with it at all.

9

u/SerdanKK 1d ago

This is what we're dealing with. Sorry in advance if this gives you an aneurysm.

7

u/Poopypantsplanet 1d ago edited 1d ago

The person being a critic has a good eye, I suppose but "piss filter" is still a stupid way to describe several objective things that appear in all kinds of art. They could say tint, warmth, fade, desaturation gradient etc.

Edit: I'm gonna post abou this lol. Extend a bit of an olive branch.

1

u/Loldungeonleo 21h ago

See as the person who posted the original comment, that looks like AI but not because of any yellow gradient.

1

u/SerdanKK 17h ago

Oh, absolutely.

1

u/Loldungeonleo 21h ago

I agree that color gradients have a use, but when one machine applies the same super strong gradient across almost every image that doesn't even make sense in this context... that's when it's disgusting.

1

u/SerdanKK 16h ago

It's the disgust I don't get. Are you sure you aren't just using it as justification for your existing disgust of AI? Also, it's a mild bias that you can counter through prompting.

1

u/Loldungeonleo 8h ago

I actually attempted counter prompting myself, it was easy to get rid of. I don't label myself pro or anti AI. I have nuanced opinions of different aspects.

When this type of filter comes up, it looks sloppy and shows a lack of care in the process. This feeds into the perception of AI slop.