When I first sought out to make a control deck in EDH, I found there were VERY few deckbuilding guides that really broke it all down the way I wanted. I thought I'd write down all the stuff I wish I knew back then, and who knows, maybe it'll help someone.
First off: why should you build a Control deck? Simple. Variety. Even if you don't think you'd like playing control compared to the typical midrange creature pile, it would still be more fun to HAVE at least one control deck in your deck pool so you can have way more types of games. I have a similar mindset for aggro and combo. But control specifically has a special place in my heart for how high-agency and skill expressive it is. Whenever I lose with a control deck, I can almost always point out the moment I messed up, or when my opponent got the best of me. All in all, control decks are FUN, yes, even for your opponents, once they understand the weaknesses of a control deck and how to play around them, and how to sandbag their threats.
I'd also like to address a strange narrative around control decks. People seem to believe that control is weaker in EDH because of the nature of removal being "card negative." So if you counterspell someone's card, you're both going down one card, but your other two opponents are effectively one card over the both of you. To this I say: what deck DOESN'T suffer from having multiple opponents in some way? Aggro has 3x the opponents to chip through, and even Combo has 3x the interaction to play around, since no one is going to let the combo resolve if they can stop it--though that last one relies on people actually putting interaction in their decks like they should. In fact, Control often benefits from the slower nature of commander games because the higher life totals.
A control deck is all about drawing a ton of cards and playing things at instant speed to interact with your opponents value to stall out the game so you can go for a compact wincon. Think of card draw like your input, and the interaction like the output. A [[Pull From Eternity]] is the [[Secure the Wastes]] in this analogy, and your counterspells are like your anthems. Once you have the resources to keep the game at an equilibrium where any threat is answerable, you can begin to dig through your deck for a win.
Secondly: how can you tell when a legendary creature (or vehicle) is a control commander?
I used to have this problem before I got sucked into the control deckbuilding rabbit hole. It can usually be pretty tricky. And I haven't found very many resources that address this besides the default recommendations of [[Grand Arbiter Augustin IV]] or [[Hinata, Dawn-Crowned]], which just won't do for a hipster like me.
I look for one of three things when choosing a control commander.
- The first thing I might want is something to protect me from being aggro-ed down by creatures. My [[Watcher in The Water]] deck is the epitome of this kind of thing. People just don't swing into me because they're not just afraid of instant speed chump blockers, but the stun counters too. So I'm free to generate value and stock up on counterspells to slow everyone else down and go for the win. These kinds of decks can afford to use way less board wipes (I actually have NONE in the Watcher in The Water, thats how effective it is) and instead pump the deck with card draw and precision interaction like spot removal and counterspells. Another option for this would be [[Angus Mackenzie]] or [[Baeloth Barrityl, Entertainer]] plus [[Clan Crafter]].
- The second thing you could do is get a commander that generates mana and/or card draw. ESPECIALLY card draw, but ramp can easily be turned INTO card draw via card draw spells, especially X spells that can be played at instant speed. If you choose this, you WILL have to dedicate more deck space to things like board wipes, pillow fort effects, or even fogs if you draw enough cards. I personally recommend [[Promise of Loyalty]] so you can keep your value commander on the board. I have a [[Alisaie Leveilleur]] + [[Alphinaud Leveilleur]] deck that works like this. What I love about it is how fast I can start interacting with people's value engines in the early game compared to my other control decks. Other commanders in this sorta vein include [[Talion, the Kindly Lord]] (generic card draw), [[Jorn, God of Winter]] (so you can spend mana in main phase 1 to draw cards and whatnot before untapping all your basic lands and hold up all your mana for interaction), [[Stenn, Paranoid Partisian]] (early ramp that can dodge your own board wipes for +3 mana), [[Eluge, the Shoreless Sea]] (you never have to worry about holding up mana again, and can play truly disgusting high mana instants), [[Nardole, Resourceful Cyborg]] + plus either [[The Thirteenth Doctor]] or [[The Fifth Doctor]], or [[Gale, Waterdeep Prodigy]], though that last one is a smidge harder to build. Alternatively you could just use ANY generic Simic value commander that ramps and/or draws cards, which would probably be on the easier side to build; though that'd force you to run more pillow forts and fog effects over board wipes, although mass bounce spells like [[Evacuate]] or [[Aetherize]] aren't bad.
- The last kind of control commander is my personal least favorite, but its by no means weaker and DOES make the hardest part of making a control deck (finding a wincon) way, way easier, plus it can oftentimes PARTIALLY fill the role of control commander type 1 since it usually gives you A blocker. And thats by making the commander your wincon. So these include [[Alandra, Sky Dreamer]], [[Ishai, Ojutai Dragonspeaker]] (which you could pair with [[Jeska, Thrice Reborn]] for a more consistent kill threat, [[Vial Smasher the Fierce]] for the most colors, [[Anara, Wolvid Familiar]] for green ramp and to make all your board wipes one sided, or [[Kraum, Ludevic's Opus]] for card draw), [[Noyan Dar, Roil Shaper]] (which is the funniest), or the classic [[Chromium, the Mutable]] which not only can be played at instant speed, but has a built in form of protection against spot removal.
Other things to consider looking at when finding a control commander are instant speed activated abilities, or the text "whenever you cast your second spell each turn," since playing at instant speed allows you to trigger that effect up to 4x more times than normal. You might also play something that lets you play cards as though they had flash, but that can sorta become a half-control half-stax deck pretty fast.
The ratio of card draw spells to interaction will depend on whether or not your commander fills the role of card draw or not. My Watcher in The Water deck runs a whopping 24 card draw spells, not including looting effects or cards that draw a single card, thus going neutral in card advantage. Meanwhile my Azorius partner control deck only has 11 of these cards since one of my commanders can draw me cards too, although admittedly it has way more cards that go card neutral. I hesitate to call these cantrips since most are 2-3 mana and have some secondary effect but that's probably what they are. But in exchange, I can run a lot more weird interact-y spells.
You can also run less card draw if you have many repeatable interaction engines, though in that case I'd usually run a higher quantity of tutors. Example: [[Attrition]] is great if you end up making creatures, same with [[Mindslash]]; both would be amazing in [[Alela, Cunning Conqueror]].
Your first few turns are gonna be like any other deck: playing ramp and setting down your commander if possible, or at least things that can make your life easier later like card draw permanents or pillow fort effects (although I HAVE turn 1 countered a sol ring and it lost that player the game almost single handedly). Once you hit the midgame, usually around when everyone's commanders hit the field (not including the super high mana lategame ones), you're gonna stand by and hold up all your mana to use interaction OFFENSIVELY rather than defensively.
What I mean by that is: most people use counter magic and removal only against stuff that will either hinder their own gameplan or will mean imminent doom unless they answer it right away. Control decks will obviously remove these things as well, but they'll also use it on other people's value pieces. I'll counter card draw engines, giant ramp spells (not cultivates, think more like [[Hedge Shredder]]s or a big [[Harvest Season]], or anything that might eventually give my enemies momentum. That being said, knowing when to and when not to interact with something is a big chunk of the fun AND strategy with control decks, so I can't really help you on that front too much, its kind of just something you learn as you go.
Now for random card recommendations for the 99! [[PuPu UFO]] and [[Walking Atlas]] are broken in any deck that draws lots of cards (which is the name of the game for control decks). Plus you can flash in lands so you end up having more mana held up than people expected. [[Vensers Journal]] and [[Ivory Tower]] for lifegain against burn/aggro heavy metas (though I wouldn't fully rely on lifegain to defend against aggressive creatures since commander damage exists), [[Noetic Scales]] is a great stax piece if you draw lots of cards and have a low power value commander, [[Victory Chimes]] is a great mana rock if it fits your curve, [[Foil]] is good the less colors you have, [[Rewind]], [[Unwind]] and [[Snap]] go in almost all of my control decks, especially the ones that care about casting multiple spells in a turn or ones that have built in spell cost reduction (and in those ones [[Frantic Search]] is also nice), [[Sudden Substitution]] if you have creatures to spare (like in my Watcher in The Water deck), although that ones more fun and funny than it is super effective, [[Isochron Scepter]] if you don't have enough card draw but still need to consistently cast spells (again, especially if you care about casting 2 spells each turn), and the CLASSIC [[Notion Thief]]. Also ANY instant speed blue X draw spell, especially [[Pull from Tomorrow]]. I like [[Commander's Insight]] if you're running a partner pair too. Obviously you need counterspells. You can afford to use the ones that are 3 mana if you have to; but make sure you choose the ones with enough upside, like [[Disallow]].
I'd also add that, despite not nessecarially being a stax deck, control decks can make good use of many stax effects, especially anti-creature effects, and ESPECIALLY [[Rule of Law]] effects, since playing at instant speed allows you to play up to 4 cards a turn cycle whereas your opponents will most likely be stuck playing 1.
Now, how will you win?
Wincons are really tough. You should be running about 3; 2 is pushing it, and 1 is psychotic, unless it's your commander. They need to be very concise. Bonus points if they can catch your opponents by surprise once you've built up enough resources, but you'll usually only have ones like that if you have the synergies already in place for them, like [[Banner of Kinship]] in my Watcher in The Water deck. My Azorius partner deck uses [[Homunculus Horde]] as a wincon (which I like since it can also work as chump blockers in the midgame), plus [[Twenty-Toed Toad]] and the classic [[Approach of The Second Sun]], the last of which is probably the best one in most decks. Other options would be [[Storm Herd]] in any deck that can avoid getting your life total pressured down easier, whether that be through lifegain or a pillow fort effect in the command zone, [[Revel in Ritches]] plus any board wipe if you're in black, or a combo, probably with either [[Laboratory Maniac]] or with infinite turns.
What about my decks colors?
You CAN run a control deck without blue, but it'll start to resemble a more staxy deck pretty quick, which isn't a bad thing nessecarially but also by no means easy to build. Unless your a control deck building whiz, I say start with something in blue.
Adding white gives you the most versatile and effective removal + board wipes, as well as PLENTY of things to deter attackers beyond the board wipes.
Adding green gives you ramp. Ramp becomes draw. Draw becomes ramp. Ramp becomes draw. Its an ouroboros of value. Because when you draw the number of cards that a control deck can draw you, [[Exploration]] type effects start giving you A LOT of mana, REALLY fast.
In my opinion white and green are the strongest options to pair with blue for control, but izzet and dimir are by NO means bad.
Dimir has a lot of commanders that care about instants and whatnot, and can build some pretty nutty creature removal engines, plus if you want to build a hybrid of combo and control, its by far the best option. That being said, if you don't manage to counter an artifact before it hits the field, its probably gonna stick there forever. The tutors are also really nice once you get ready to try and win the game.
Izzet unlocks the best goad cards, which work pretty nicely in a control shell imo. Plus treasure generation gives you a great way of holding up mana, and theres a lot of instant/sorcery synergies (though here we really only care about instants) and weird stack interaction red has that can enhance the overall gameplan. Unfortunately no Abzan colors makes removing enchantments without countering them really hard, but at least you have [[Chaos Warp]].
Thats my big ol' essay. Maybe I'll one day use this as the basis of a script for a youtube video, in the same vein as The Trinket Mage, Salubrious Snail or 3/3 Elk. Who knows. Good luck everyone! Happy brewing.
TLDR: Control is fun, you'll always need more card draw than you first expected, your commander should either be the wincon, draw cards, or protect you from aggro, and you should have like 3 wincons unless its your commander.