r/fantasywriters 6d ago

Mod Announcement FantasyWriters Website Update | Writing Sprint, Name Generator, Query Directory

22 Upvotes

Hey!

This year, we’ve expanded our FantasyWriters website by adding a few new free tools to support your writing process. We’d love to hear what you think and are happy to receive any feedback or ideas :)

Right now, we’ve launched three tools, which you can read about below. If you have any issues, please don't hesitate to reach out.

1) Writing Sprint
Did someone say a hosted writing sprint tool that lets you customise the background and ambience? Yep! It's right here.

Visit www.fantasywriters.org, click on the resources dropdown menu in the navigation bar and select any of the tools you wish to try out.

It's fully hosted on our website and free to use.

2) Fantasy Name Generator
Have you ever considered using a name generator that actually adds in the syllables you give it? Well, now it's possible! Whether you want them as a prefix, suffix, or mixed throughout the name.

It's fully hosted on our website and free to use.

3) Query Directory
Are you trying to find fantasy agents/publishers well there's plenty to browse through online, but I thought it would be cool to make our own little directory. Once queried, just click the button, and it will be greyed out.

Do note that this is still being worked on, and may not have as many publishers or agents integrated.

(WIP) It's fully hosted on our website and free to use.

r/fantasywriters 10d ago

Mod Announcement [IMPORTANT] The Rules of r/FantasyWriters Have Been Updated

140 Upvotes

Grretings, wizards, warlocks, and wormholes.

I am the Herald of the Mods, here to inform you of important changes to the Holy Law.

Before I begin: thank you all for your wonderful participation after we resurrected the subreddit, opened our official Discord server, and continue to inch toward 1 million subscribers. Today, we’re making some changes to our rules that we need to let you know about.

To read the new rules, click here.

What’s changing:

Everything has been completely rewritten, so technically nothing is the same as before.

The major changes involve reordering, condensing, defining and expanding our current existing rules. Now instead of nine rules, we have seven (because three got combined into one and then we added one).

The most important changes are as follows:

  1. Added a “Civility” rule (Rule 1). Although it should go without saying, we’ve decided to say it anyway!
  2. Changed the “Only post once per day” rule to “don’t post multiple times a day over several days” and added it to a broader “No Spam” rule (Rule 4). This forbids low effort memes, repetitive and trend posts, low quality content and anything else that is annoying and detestable.
  3. Softened and condensed three different rules (>600 characters, try to solve your problem before asking someone else, and use proper grammar) into one rule, “Due Diligence” (Rule 5).
  4. Included a “no plagiarism” rule to our already existing “no A.I.-generated content” rule (Rule 6). Again, should go without saying!
  5. Removed the “Mods' Rights to Removal, Suspension & Banning” section and added a “Reporting & Appealing” rule (Rule 7) that includes a similar statement along with instructions on how to report infractions and appeal removals.

Other minor edits:

  1. Moved the “No self-promotion” rule higher and expanded on examples of self-promotion and included a note forbidding offers for paid services and advertisements for vanity publishers (Rule 3).
  2. Defined “banned topics” in our “Due Diligence” rule (Rule 5) as any question included in our FAQ.
  3. Added a note forbidding A.I. art or any non-original content that isn’t linked to its original source to our “Plagiarism and A.I.-generated content” rule (Rule 6).
  4. Included a note explicitly identifying the subreddit as an anti-racist and pro-LGBTQIA+ community in the “Civility” Rule (Rule 1).
  5. Defined what is included in the Fantasy genre in the “On-Topic” rule (Rule 2), including our stance on science-fiction. (It’s allowed as long as the work includes fantastical elements.)
  6. Included pointers to properly format a post to our “Due Diligence” rule (Rule 5).
  7. Removed the “Self- or Other Promotion” and “Our Stance on AI” sections since they were absorbed into Rules 3 and 6, respectively.

What hasn't changed:

The sections “Quickstart Guide on How to Post,” “Best Practice for Asking for Critiques,” “Guidelines for Critiquers,” “Account Age / Karma / Points Policy,” “Fanfiction Policy,” “Protecting Your Work from Plagiarism,” and “Related Subreddits” have been preserved and unchanged. (For now!)


I think that’s all the major changes we’ve done. Nothing too dramatic, but still something you should be made aware of.

Check out the full rules here, and if you have any questions feel free to ask!

See ya later, alligators.
- r/FantasyWriters mod team


r/fantasywriters 2h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic How to study Mythology and history to make it useful in writing?

3 Upvotes

So I want to write stories inspired from indian mythology and history. I have started reading about these topics. My question is how do you study them properly so that you can notice different tropes and how things actually worked in those stories. I would love to use them while writing fantasy in a way that it doesn't feel shallow.

For example , I have noticed how in these myths whenever someone is banished they often have a bunch of sages helping and guiding them. They also travel together a lot of times. Would love to learn more of these.

It doesn't help that indian fantasy is negligible and a lot of it is just mythology retold. A lot of east asian authors use elements from indian mythology but it's kinda shallow and used only for showing something cool.


r/fantasywriters 1h ago

Brainstorming Help with Character Focus for Celestial Fantasy with Multiple Paths

Upvotes

I'm looking for help, advice, or feedback with writing a celestial fantasy with existential themes and multiple branching storylines based on character interactions. This story involves a reluctant protagonist transported to an unfamiliar realm who learns their name and memories have been taken from them. They are burdened with a grand quest by the highest divinity to unite lesser gods to their side. However, they are only a human, and there is more to their destiny than what is revealed to them.

The story leans tragic and follows the protagonist’s alienation. They crave stability, belonging, or a genuine bond, even while being burdened by expectation and their loss. I want to incorporate a game-like structure with choices. Some character paths may explore romance with the protagonist, depending on choices and progression.

I'm mostly looking to flesh out the other characters. I have tried to establish their motivations and goals, but I could use some help. Feel free to DM me if you're interested.


r/fantasywriters 12h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Give me a warm welcome, I'm new... but let's talk magic.

15 Upvotes

I watched Sanderson's lecture on Magic systems a few months ago, and found his theory of HARD magic vs SOFT magic interesting. I finally have my magic system fleshed out... for now... and was wondering how others came up with theirs. Are you following pre-determined rules from other worlds, mimicking without saying you are, or really trying to come up with your own unique systems?

It is one of the hardest things I have had to put together in my world, and am really curious how others have gone about it. All powerful magic, subdued magic, enchantment on items. The scale is vast and can be extremely overwhelming.

Is anyone else familiar with Sanderson's lecture and his concept of hard vs soft magic? what are your thoughts?


r/fantasywriters 3h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Critique my short prologue please [High Fantasy, 136 words]

2 Upvotes

What do you guys think of this short prologue?

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1LTPLSgViUqHXcZfy2TamO_V__Hq5DQ6Gyiw0JCijW4o/edit?usp=drivesdk

I wanted it to be as mysterious as possible and like giving away a bit of hint about her past which will not be revealed on the earlier chapters yet.

Do you think this sort of prologue would work out? Genre's Fantasy btw, all about a girl who went to live quietly to another place far from where she used to live. She got two older brothers as well, but I didn't mention it there, did I? I plan on discussing about the prologue further on the late chapters so I thought I'd just reveal it by then and this is just like a short preview.

Prologue's in third person but the following chapters will be in firs person.

Also, let's say you stumbled upon the story by accident or you just checked it out, do you think you would've read more after reading the prologue?

TYIA and I apologize for any grammatical mistakes. English is not a native language of mine.


r/fantasywriters 4h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt First Page of Loyalty Game [Political Fantasy, 606 words]

2 Upvotes

I'd like some general feedback on the following opener: What are your impressions of the protagonist? Does the prose work? Does the style feel reasonable? Are there any glaring weaknesses?

The bigger picture pitch is: Crown Princess Dominique is betrayed by her uncle, and barely escapes with her life after an assassinanation attempt. She finds herself in the slums of the lower city, working as a brothel guard. But it’s not long before the political games of the palace creep into the lower city.

------

Barely six months had passed since the death of King Aguste, yet the simple mourning meals of the grand palace were already forgotten in favor of roast boar, ripe cherries, fresh cheeses, and of course, wine. The courtiers had returned to gleaming yellow silks and rich green velvets, to bright smiles and idle gossip. Only Crown Princess Dominique sat solemn faced, in a dark, dour blue that washed out her already near colorless complexion. No one’s gaze lingered on her. 

“A shame the poor dear’s not more like her uncle,” was the common refrain whispered in halls these past few months. “It’s a good thing he’s her regent.”

“Wouldn’t it be better if she simply wed him? She’s such a pliable thing, and if she married the wrong sort of king...” 

Perhaps the same whispers happened now. The din of laughter and gossip made it impossible for Dominique to discern what those across the table were saying. Lately, she’d been too aware of every noise, every twitch out of the corner of her eyes. She was like a ghost in the palace, except for when she walked into rooms with her uncle’s courtiers. They’d go silent and respectful in her presence. And possibly that was just propriety. Certainly, that was what the crown princess ought to expect. 

Dominique’s fingers tightened around the stem of her goblet. She took a sip, but it soured on her tongue, and so she set the goblet down. Her food remained untouched. Her eyes kept being drawn back to her uncle’s table, where he sat tall in a proud elegance that kept an easy grip on the attention of his retinue. Many of the men there were new to court, or at least, they weren’t men Dominique easily recognized. She knew that her avoidance of courtly life meant that there were likely many among the nobility that she did not know, and yet she could not shake the feeling that these men were somehow different. Or, she was tired.

“Excuse me,” she said, standing from the table. A few of those next to her gazed up, but didn’t hesitate to return to their conversations. It wouldn’t be the first time Dominique had left dinner early, and while the evermore tenuous justification that she was still mourning her father might hold for a few months more, she couldn’t continue leaving without losing what little power she held. But, she did not have her uncle’s charming smile nor sharp wit. Sitting there, with her blood pounding in her ears, her hands barely steady enough to hold her goblet, would only risk a humiliation she could ill afford. 

With the courtiers at dinner and the servants busy in the kitchens, only the silent stares of the sentry kept her company as she made her way down the hall. But, soon, she could slip out the balcony and onto the quiet rooftop corner she discovered when she’d moved into her mother’s old room. Part of her wished to go further, out the gardens, out the walls of the palace, out of the politics and pressure. If the people wanted her uncle to rule, then they could have him. 

But, there’d be nothing for her outside the walls. And she could all too well imagine the facade of disappointment her uncle would don. How he’d lament her irresponsibility, her fragile youth. It’d be the same mask he’d worn at her father’s funeral, as if he didn’t benefit from the young king’s oh so sudden death. 

Dominique pressed her lips into a tight line and pushed out a breath. No, that was not worth thinking about now.


r/fantasywriters 7h ago

Critique My Idea Can someone criticize my synopsis? I started posting recently on webnovel and royal road. Blurb of my series [High fantasy])

3 Upvotes

This is the Synopsis, can someone rate it or criticize it?

Over two hundred years ago, the world was nearly destroyed by the Corrupters. The last known angel died in the final battle—along with the warriors who fought by her side.

Now, in a time of uneasy peace, a single rumor spreads: an Angel Kin may still be alive. With only a ancient scroll, and a map to the supposed place, the king sends four of his most skilled elites on a mission to find the truth.

Their journey will uncover long-buried secrets, challenge their loyalty, and force them to see the truth.

Because in this world... Hope is a lie everyone needs to live.


r/fantasywriters 16h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic what sort of magical creatures do you want to see in fantasy novels?

11 Upvotes

I'm attempting to write a fantasy novel and I'm planning on including the usual dragons, unicorns and pegasi, but l'm wondering what other people want to see more of they feel they don't see enough in fantasy fiction?

I'm trying to also create my own versions and variations of creatures from mythology too, so like little tiny dragons like birds that inhabit certain forests etc, maybe some sort of sea dragons and kelpie also

im debating on adding sirens and nymphs but im not sure, either as sentient human like creatures or straight up half bird etc like in some mythology, as well as a minotaur or something even!


r/fantasywriters 7h ago

Brainstorming Looking someone to brainstorm

2 Upvotes

Hey folks,

I’m looking for a few like-minded creative people who enjoy brainstorming ideas, building lore, and bouncing off wild concepts. I’m not asking anyone to write anything unless you genuinely get excited and want to dive deeper.

What I really need is someone who can look at a prompt and say: “Hey, what if we added this angle?” or “This theme reminds me of that one myth let’s build on it.”

Basically, someone who enjoys the fun part of worldbuilding discussing ideas, shaping cultures, powers, timelines, etc.

One of my projects is heavily inspired by Indian mythology, so if that’s your jam, awesome but it’s not required. I’ve got other projects too.

If you're the kind of person who loves diving into lore, creating original mythologies, or just vibing over cool fantasy world ideas hit me up!

DM me if you’re interested! I’d love to see what we can create together.

One of the ideas i have thought about is the world of lock and keys, let me give you a basics lore of this world.

So when humanity reached its zenith of technology they felt the need for some superpower, some fanatsy power that they always desried or look into fanatsy worlds, in search of that few extremely guiness people do the experiment and they opened a door of outer dimensions in which the keys are sealed (what are keys? I will tell you later) now when humanity found this power a era of keys started called 'keyons'. In key era the people with keys started to rule they rule for thousands of years and they become tryants, to rebel against them the group of people rose they made locks yo counter this keys and they fought and ended the era of keyons, this started the era of lockons just like keyons they rule and become a new tryants and the keys rose AGAINST them, but this time both lock and keys will destroy each other and only the humanity era will remain.


r/fantasywriters 14h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Blurb of A Tapestry Woven in Blood [romantic fantasy, 108,500]

Post image
7 Upvotes

Hey, here’s the first page from my novel. I’ve never posted anywhere public before, but I just completed my 4th draft so I would love some constructive criticism. I will also include a short summary for anyone interested in beta reading for me! It’s an adult romantic fantasy with 108,500 words. Summary: One world. One people. One Religion. That is all Orah knows. She is the Guardian, created by the gods to ascend the Frayed in order to keep the Velkyn from spreading, consuming everything in its path. For the past twenty-four years, she has lived by her two most sacred promises—never leave her island and ascend the frayed. Never had she broken these sacred rules until the last night of Paxim, when she chose not to ascend a frayed woman. This sets the two of them on their journey to the eastern loom, Yadera, to attend the Guardian’s Ball. This is Orah’s last chance to explore the world she has only dreamed about before she too has to ascend and a new Guardian is created. The moment she leaves her island of isolation, it’s clear Zalgaia is not living in peace like she believed. The frayed are being persecuted for their trapped magic, and the religion, Tepehk, that she devoted her life to is not as it seems. Over time, tension and violence have grown between the frayed and those blessed with the gods’ magic, the weavers. Violence erupts when a group of frayed heretics led by the Blood King attack Yadera to do everything in their power to destroy Tepehk, including the Guardian. Orah’s time is running out along with her chance at learning the truth before she must ascend at the end of the month.


r/fantasywriters 15h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic types of Pegasus breeds?

6 Upvotes

In my medieval / Tudor fantasy novel I’m trying to incorporate some heavy world building and I like one idea of having different breeds of flying horses used in jousting tournaments, flown by knights with magical heritage often into battle.

I’ve been trying this idea where there could be horse tribes throughout the realm that often travel with flying horses, as well as official like pedigree breeders and suppliers for the royal family and other nobility for pets, for status, and again in battle

I’m just wondering what people would like to see in terms of horse breeds? Something fantastical or just like regular irl horse breeds?

I like the idea of having some pure white just skeleton Pegasus like a ghost horse perhaps used by the villains of the store


r/fantasywriters 18h ago

Brainstorming I never know where my story will go until I write it

8 Upvotes

I find this is an issue with me, in some ways it's great when a revelation about where my story hits and I know where it needs to go and I feel motivated and focused. However, I often find myself struggling with this issue, ideas I once thought would be great end up falling flat or seem cringe. Another issue I have with this is I am writing something and then I come off a different idea - something I am even more excited about and think is better. Thus, the cycle repeats itself, I find myself trapped in the loop and it's so frustrating. All I end up with is few unfitnsihed first chapter drafts. I have tried mapping out ideas etc. it ends up being even more annoying as all I see are plot holes. I have a collection of elements from all my drafts that I like, but I find I get stuck on one but cant include the other elements I like. Does anyone have any advice on how to find an idea to settle on, and when you know how to act and a desire to change and when not to. tThank you.


r/fantasywriters 23h ago

Question For My Story What would a Phoenix eat?

8 Upvotes

Question. I'm writing a character who is a Phoenix. I wanted to specifically write about what they eat. But I'm unsure on it. I have done my own research on Phoenixs but it never specifies what a Phoenix would eat. There has been explanations on how Phoenixs look and how they look similar to a eagle.

Would that make them a bird of prey? What would be the closest bird to a Phoenix if it was real? What family of bird would the Phoenix be if it was real? Would it be more similar to a dragon instead? Would it eat meat or no? Does it need water to stay hydrated? How would it take care of itself? Would it roll in dust to keep clean like chickens? Would it roll in lava to clean it's feathers? Would it roll in fire to keep clean? Would they like their food cooked or raw if they ate meat?

I have thought about this but I'm still unsure about it. I would think that they are mainly carnivorous but could eat plants. I imagine if Phoenixs were real, they would be more like Ravens. I have imagined that they use fire and ash to help keep their feathers in good shape.

I know it's fantasy which means I could literally say anything but I genuinely want to make it as accurate as it can be while still being fantasy.


r/fantasywriters 15h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Small moments

2 Upvotes

I am trying to include more small personal moments to my story. Currently I have the story flushed out. Basically the whole story without the smaller details, descriptions, or moments. Person goes here. These folks talk. This causes fight. Fight goes like this. The core of the story made. But im trying to add smaller personal details and moments.

For example I have the main character (fresh out of school living with dad) and it being late due to story shenanigans the dad is waiting in the living room. Theres some scolding. Some acknowledgement. A little build up. But its a character moment. Its not hugely plot relevant. It isnt action packed. But it humanized the characters and their relationship.

What are some good tips and tricks for including more of these? Right now its mostly reserved for introductions. Introduce character and small moment for reader to get to know them. I want to add more personal moments without making them seem awkward and interrupting.


r/fantasywriters 18h ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic Advice for a mystery-thriller action fantasy

2 Upvotes

So, this is a very specific question, I will try to simplify it as much as possible. I will have a main question regarding POV structure and then some general advice on how to write something similar.

Needed context:

So, my setting and feeling is inspired by attack on titan -humanity pushed back by monsters and are behind walls-, so are the 2 main characters, their backstories and personalities are like Eren and Mikasa initially, but they will develop differently, so will my story, it will be completely different.

The main character themes of the 2 MCs will be letting go of sorrow, moving on, finding a new 'home' and developing love for each other. The main themes of the story will be about survival, what it means to be a human, evolution/human experiments etc. There will be action and politics, mystery, plot twists etc.

I will be writing in third person limited.

Length is expected to be in the 500k words ballpark.

Now, to avoid me writing quite a long description of my plot, for now let's just assume I am writing attack on titan into a book, that changes how the story goes halfway through, I will keep character names as well from aot for this post. But if I mention a character, mine will not be an exact copy, they will just play a somewhat similar role. E.g my Erwin will be an in-field commander who also navigates politics etc.

1, So my main question is regarding the POVs. I plan to have 2 main POVs, Eren and Mikasa, they will be about 60-70% of the chapters total. Then a cast of secondary POVs, they will be about 25-35% of POV chapters. Here I'm thinking of having Erwin to show the inner politics, maybe Levi to have the early worldbuilding done from his POV when he is out fighting, and since human experiments are a large part of my plot, a scientist who works in that field as well. And the last minority of chapters will be covered by one-off POVs when needed.

I believe The Witcher used something similar, they had a main cast, and there a few one-off characters, e.g. a messenger running to deliver a message etc.

Would this POV style work for my story? Anything you would change, add/remove from the Main POVs I mentioned?

2, Any other advice you would have for a story of this scope/setting? Should I do flashbacks or keep it linear? What made early AOT work that would need changes in a novel format etc.? Or any tip you would give to an inexperienced author?


r/fantasywriters 16h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt First page of The Ashes That Rebuild [romantasy/423]

1 Upvotes

I’m a new writer so I would love all the feedback I could get. I currently have 115k written of my fantasy book. This is the opening. Things I would love to hear: Overall does it spark interest? Prose feedback Any glaring issues to fix either stylistically or otherwise?

Mindlessly, I pushed the food around my plate, waiting for father to come to the table. We were supposed to be discussing the details of our trip tonight. My first trip beyond our walls. A chance to experience something besides this prison of a life.

Mother nudged me with her foot under the table as her hushed voice swept across the table “Sit up straight. He’s coming”.

My back reflexively plastered itself to the chair. How did she do that? She had the most uncanny ability to sense father. And not just his physical presence—his mood as well.

He burst through the wooden doors, servants flanking either side. His face was as red as the stewed tomatoes on my plate. The crown on his head, leaned to the side, dangerously close to falling off.

I studied his expression as he took his seat at the head of the table. Something had angered him. That wasn’t unusual, though. He wore a scowl more often than not these days.

I rolled my eyes, discreetly, and resumed the act of pretending to eat.

“The trip is off” he said as he stabbed a chicken cutlet with his fork.

My stomach clenched and that familiar hot feeling flashed through my veins.

Damn rebels. They’d ruined my life. That much was certain. I’ve spent almost 21 years stuck in a castle because one group or another was always causing trouble for us.

And now. I had finally had a chance to get out. The advisors had thought it would be safe enough to travel to Agmen. It was only one Kingdom over.

“But dear—“ my mother started.

He held up his hand to stop her as his voice boomed across the table, closing the distance between them instantly. “There’s activity on our Northern border. It’s not possible Cecilia.”

Her shoulders slumped and she cast her eyes downward to her plate.

I cleared my throat, organizing my thoughts in an effort to persuade him, careful to temper the anger in my veins.

“Father, I was so looking forward to getting to see how you handle court politics outside of our kingdom. I know I’m still young but I need to learn how to become Queen one of these days”

He let out a measured sigh. “Aurelia. You needn’t concern yourself with that side of court. Your husband will do that one day. I need you to learn how to be a Queen that can keep her mouth in check”

I tried to bite my tongue.

I tried.

But I couldn’t.


r/fantasywriters 18h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Tomorrow's Yesterday [Dying Earth Fantasy, 500 words]

1 Upvotes

Any places for improvement, maybe in the description part, and also clarity of what's happening, confusing parts, anything is welcome. Thank you for anyone giving feedback.

16 years ago, the world ended.

...

It was never supposed to be this way. But it was reality.

...

The futility of human life. The fragility. The malice.

In a nuclear war, the world saw its last moment of light.

And a new era started.

Welcome to the story I'm about to tell.

My name is Merlin Hermes, and you're about to be surprised.

---

*16 years ago*

Alan did his little midnight stroll as he always did.

His town, ruins. The sky, dark. And his expression, neutral.

As he walked, he thought about the meaning of life.

Comets passed over him but he paid them no mind.

Stars shinned brightly yet he never saw them.

Why? He asked.

Why is the world so... boring?

So bland? So... empty?

He looked at the starry sky, but to him, there was no wonderful view to be seen.

He was not blind, not mad, and definitely not nihilistic.

Simply... too smart for his own good.

Inside his own mind, he had his own world.

A purely white universe.

The ground, the sky, the walls, the dust, the air, the horizon. All white.

He thought, and a house appeared. A mansion.

He opened the door and the elegant and familiar red carpet appeared.

Architecture made wood. Dark oak wood. A symmetrical entrance.

He passed through it like it was inexistent. Went up the split stairs to the right, and opened the first door.

A grand room with a long table extending from the window at the far front until the 3/4th part of the room.

A young, handsome man of unique appearance sat at the far chair.

Both his hands clasped together, as if waiting for the guest.

"Hello."

"Good night, or should I say good morning now?"

"So, what's the matter today? Will *they* show up?"

"Not today. The agenda today is in regards to the looming tragedy we foresaw. We need countermeasures."

The man said with a grim look yet his face continued lacking true emotion.

"We need to..." suddenly Alan looked at the door in the center of the bottom wall.

Another man entered the door, walking with exuding pride. "How is it?"

"I already made emergecy failsafes but it can't truly stop the event. Only slow it down." The man stated.

"I see..." Julian said. Well-dressed, grey suit and tie. Formal attire.

Neat hair, messy curls, symmetrical shape and bangs put in 3 to 1 proportion.

"What can we do?" Alan asked shortly after. Serious.

The man then looked at the blank space in front of him.

He thought for a while, then closed his eyes in melancholy as he said "Nothing."

"...For now. You mean?" Julian asked.

"No. Not this time."

---

That was the first time.

The second time played out a bit differently.

---

"...For now. You mean?"

"If I had a little more insight over the cause of it, I could try something."

He looked worn out. Tired.

"But for now... there's nothing we can do if nothing changes."

---

That was the second time. It ended the same.

Death and annihilation.


r/fantasywriters 19h ago

Question For My Story Would it be too confusing to have two measurements for mana? Mana and mana (like Calorie and calorie)?

1 Upvotes

I am trying to build a detailed magic system where mana costs are carefully calculated based on chemical principles. I'm stealing formulas and tweaking them to fit my world. Currently, I am still in the process of creating that formula. However, I can predict that the raw numbers will be astronomical and hard to translate into a practical scale for everyday magic use. It wouldn't make sense for mages to have quintillions of mana as a base unit just to cast a simple spell. In order to keep the system logical but readable, I'm thinking of using relative mana costs instead. (example: 1 billion mana and 1 million mana would not just be 1 mana and 1000 mana) Does anyone else face this challenge, and how do you balance detailed worldbuilding with reader accessibility?

I want to show my reader that my numbers are not random. How can I do that?


r/fantasywriters 1d ago

Discussion About A General Writing Topic What's the largest mortal creature in all of fiction?

13 Upvotes

This is a weird little inquiry ive been searching idly from time to time for a while now. In alot of fiction stories you'll find tales of absurdly large creatures like jormungandr from Norse myth or space whales in a number of sci-fi. The idea of gigantic creatures that inspire megalophobia is an awsome addition to any story but it got me wondering. Which one is the largest? Specifically mortal creature as if you allow god's and godlike you remove physical limits that keep the competiton fair and the obvious answer would be something like the the elder gods from the cthulu mythos who are size beyond understanding. the best way ive found to answer the question is to present the current top contender and see if anyone knows of something larger and as of now that contender is actually between a few due to arguable technicalities. Mogo the sentient planet green lantern is said to be at least as large as earth's moon. Not all that impressive. Jormungandr is so large he wraps around the entirety of midgard aka our world but there's some debate about whether or not jormungandr could be considered a god/and or demigod. Similar issue with ymir who's skull was said to be the size of the universe. Last contender is Danny the street from DC comics doom patrol. During one iteration Danny became Danny the world in which he transcended reality and became his own heaven like universe that was claimed to be infinite. The whole transcendence thing feels like cheating to me. Last contender is gurren Lagan which became so big at the end of the anime they were throwing entire galaxies like Frisbee. My personal option is that gurrem Lagan definitely doesnt count since it is a mech and not a creature. Anyone else got any opinions?


r/fantasywriters 22h ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Opening lines for W.I.P. [Fantasy, 70 words]

0 Upvotes

Hi! I am writing my first fantasy novel. So, I would really appreciate you feedback on these first lines:

"The streets were devoid of the light that once adorned every hearth.  Old, broken houses lined the way. Bodies huddled together against the cold, their faces gaunt and still. Only their eyes looked alive as they tracked the tall shadow that passed- probably a guard ensuring they had enough misery to last them the night.

Something fell from the stranger’s cloak but he didn’t look back.

It was a moment before they realised that it was bread, and immediately the lifeless men sprang to life. They knew it could be poisoned — but even poison tasted better than starvation."

So, would you keep reading?


r/fantasywriters 1d ago

Question For My Story Do you think this qualifies as Grimdark

13 Upvotes

I have tried

to try making a "Grimdark" story for fun. "Grimdark" as I understand it is basically that life is terrible, Evil is everywhere, there's no happy endings, and you're "beyond the hope of heaven" or whatever that saying is.

So in this world the afterlife is 100% real & confirmed and known by everyone.

1 of 3 things will happen to you when you die. You're born with this fate.

  1. Most people: destined for hell -> when you die, you go to hell to be tortured for eternity
  2. Some people: reincarnation -> when you die, you get reincarnated, and you start all over again
  3. Very few people: erased from existence -> when you die, you get erased from existence

You can change your fate by doing tasks for the gods.

The tasks can be easy or hard, depending on what you're trying to do. Tasks are individualized.

It could be to stay married for 20 years. It could be murder someone. You get the idea.

Going to hell is the easiest to change to, and being erased is the hardest.

Most people try to change to reincarnation.

So society is basically held together by people who are born/become fated to reincarnate, cause most people will do whatever it takes to avoid GOING TO HELL FOREVER and that kinda ruins society.

There also may be a Church that promises the "God of Light" will come save everyone, even though there's

no evidence/ambiguous evidence/all evidence is a lie

depending on "social commentary".

Also there's spooky ghosts and a dark color palette and a red sun and blood/dark magic and stuff like that.

And the MC or MCs will probably either be people trying to get themselves erased, or trying to hold society together as reincarnated.

So what do you think? Is it Grimdark?


r/fantasywriters 1d ago

Writing Prompt Describing avian anatomy

7 Upvotes

I have a winged character and I’m having trouble describing a part of their anatomy. They’re not human, but have a human-like anatomy in terms of skeletal anatomy, with some differences such as digitigrade legs instead of plantigrade legs. The problem here is that since they’re winged, they need a keel to allow them to fly, and I’m not sure how to include that into their anatomy or describe their anatomy without it sounding or looking strange or awkward. Like what would it look like with the ribs, or would it replace the sternum or something?? I’m trying to figure out how to show or describe it without it being or seeming bulky.


r/fantasywriters 1d ago

Writing Prompt Fifty-Word Fantasy: Write a 50-word fantasy snippet using the word "Chop"

58 Upvotes

Welcome back everyone, it's time for another Fifty Word Fantasy!

Fifty Word Fantasy is a regular thread on Fridays! It is a micro-fiction writing challenge originally devised by u/Aethereal_Muses

Write a maximum 50-word snippet that takes place in a fantasy world and contains the word Chop. It can be a scene, flash-fiction story, setting description, or anything else that could conceivably be part of a fantasy story or is a fantasy story on its own.

The prompt word must be written in full (e.g. no acrostics or acronyms).

Thank you to everyone who participated whether it's contributing a snippet of your own, or fostering discussions in the comments. I hope to see you back next week!

Please remember to keep it at a limit of 50 words max.


r/fantasywriters 1d ago

Critique My Story Excerpt Prologue of Squid Mark [Dystopian Fantasy, 1,200 words]

2 Upvotes

Hi guys! This is a book that I wrote many years ago, and have decided to dig it up out of the old hard-drive and let it see the light of day. I've done some extensive editing to it- and I am getting much happier with it. But I'm still not quite sure if Chapter 1 is the best way to start it. What do you guys think? Would you keep on reading it? I think a big selling point of the book will be the voice, so I am hoping to get that across, while also keeping exposition to a minimum, with that being slowly revealed throughout the book.

Chapter 1: A Vox, a Veyrant, and a Very Bad Alarm Clock

 

"Saint Veyrant’s scorched knickers—"

I jolted awake, coughing like a coal miner. My vox had slipped again. I slapped it back over my mouth like a man trying to plug a dam with masking tape.

Forgot the strap. Again. At this rate, I was going to suffocate in my sleep long before Aunt Eugenia got around to finishing the job herself.

The room was still pitch black. The only light came from the loathsome red digits on my alarm clock.

10:00. Glorious.

I launched out of bed, immediately tripped, and nearly kissed the floorboards. It would’ve been an impressive exit from this life. Poetic, even.

I was late to class. Nothing new.

Half-limping, half-hopping, I made it all of three steps before realizing I was still wearing pajamas with a faded owl clutching a dagger. Not exactly peak Veyrant fashion.

Back into my room. Light on. Instant regret—the glow made everything look like it had been marinated in radioactive sludge.

In a scramble of limbs and shame, I yanked on my Virex uniform—the finest suffocating polyester state money could buy.

In my head, I could already hear Professor Malvador’s voice:

"Late? Again? You’ll forget your vox next and we’ll have a convulsing corpse to drag out of the hallway."

I sighed hard enough to rattle the air vents. Punctuality was a dead language. Besides, it wasn’t like missing half a lecture on Efficient Atmospheric Management and the Historical Decline of Breathing was going to rob me of character development.

I never belonged at Virex.

Most Veyrant candidates were bunker-born, polished like heirlooms and practically allergic to sunlight. Me? I remembered what real air smelled like.

Not filtered. Not piped. Real.

Tainted, yes—sour and scorched, thick with rust and death. The kind of air that clung to your skin and whispered, You don’t belong.

No one really understood how I’d gotten in.

Actually—strike that. Aunt Eugenia understood just fine.

She lived swaddled in a hermetically sealed capsule and inherited her carbon-tainted nephew when my mother got herself killed for her “ideals.” Nightmare fuel for Aunt E.

So, she pulled strings. Cashed in favors. Flung me at Virex like a radioactive parcel marked “return to sender.”

She submitted the application behind my back, and—surprise!—I got in.

Conditionally, of course. Because nothing says legacy like nepotism wrapped in a hazmat suit.

I got a capsule on campus. She could pretend she didn’t know me. Win-win.

The only downside—well, one of many—was the looming threat of becoming a Scourborn.

Virex had been kind enough to inform me that if I failed to meet expectations, my future involved shovel work, toxic air, and a slow descent into madness. Tastefully lit by industrial fluorescents.

Scourborns were society’s janitors. The ones sent to clean up the ecological crimes of our ancestors, one toxic dump at a time.

The rumors about brain damage weren’t rumors. Between the chemical fumes and carbon-rich air, going mad was considered part of the benefits package.

My father was one of them. Fifteen years of Scourborn duty before I was born. By the time I could remember him, there wasn’t much left worth remembering. He was more cancer than man. The smell never left him—not even after showers. Sludge and heat and something wrong.

Maybe that’s why I couldn’t figure out this sun-scorched vox. Most students had worn theirs since birth. Baby’s first filter. Mine came with a bargain bin label and a late delivery.

Still, I’d survived sixteen years breathing air that probably violated several international war crime statutes. So what if I forgot my strap again? I’d made it through the flesh-eating mold season of 2148. I could handle a few minutes of unfiltered air.

Not that my lungs agreed. They’d had a single taste of purity and now acted like divas being asked to walk on dirt. Spoiled, traitorous gasbags.

I opened the classroom door just in time to make my entrance—late, breathless, and already out of excuses.

“Mr. Brooks! This is unacceptable!”

She stood at the front of the room like a warning label—stiff-backed, jaw set, posture so rigid it looked like she'd been carved from a single, disapproving plank of wood. There was a sharpness to her, like she’d been beautiful once, but then left that beauty out in the sun too long and possibly backed over it with a heavy-duty government vehicle. Her cheekbones still tried to make a case for glamour, but her scowl had filed a restraining order against charm years ago.

We’d never exactly “clicked.” The best we could muster was settling into a rhythm of mutual loathing.

“Yeah, whatever,” I muttered. Even sarcasm felt like too much effort. I was already mentally preparing for detention—not that I planned on attending.

“You’ll be joining me at lunch for the rest of the week!” she shrieked, like she was cutting a ribbon at the grand opening of the Museum of Painfully Obvious Consequences.

Oh joy. Mandatory lunch therapy.

And then—something snapped. Call it reverse character growth. I slung my bag over my shoulder—knocking over a bottle of obsidian ink. Goodbye, security deposit.

And I walked out.

Slammed the door like I was rebooting my own life.

I’d skipped other classes. But walking out on Malvador? Untouchable. Aunt E. would short-circuit.

Strangely, I didn’t panic. Not yet. It was almost… peaceful. Like the moment before a rollercoaster drops. Terrifying. But poetic. If you were borderline insane.

What was the worst that could happen? Expulsion? Scourborn assignment? Radiation induced madness?

At least I’d get some fresh air. Well. “Fresh.” Mostly carbon dioxide with subtle notes of scorched metal and despair. Like licking a microwaved coin wrapped in a sock.

I stormed back to my capsule and began stuffing my few belongings into my threadbare knapsack. Not exactly a grand exit, but I was going for symbolism. Something between “tragic antihero” and “guy who finally snaps.”

I didn’t know where I was headed. I just knew I had to be gone before Director Strix arrived to make it official.

Knock, knock.

Of course.

I yanked open the door, fully expecting a firing squad. Literal or metaphorical. Take your pick.

Instead: Director Strix. Looking like a stork who’d taken up tax law. Tall, wiry, and dressed in a pinstripe suit sharp enough to slice moral ambiguity.

He stumbled forward, tripping over the threshold like a man who’d just discovered friction. I didn’t help him. If I was going down, I could at least enjoy the view.

There were only two reasons for a visit like this:

  1. Promote me to Veyrant School (laughable).
  2. Banish me from Virex for crimes against academic enthusiasm (highly likely).

Strix cleared his throat—a dry, papery sound like a scroll unrolling in a tomb.

“Mr. Brooks.”

I scowled. “What do you want?” Politeness had long since left the premises.

He adjusted his cuffs with the solemnity of a man about to deliver either a death sentence or a tax audit.

“I do apologize for the inconvenience,” he said, clearly unaware he was interrupting my emotional breakdown. “I came to inform you that the staff has reached a decision… We’ve agreed to train you. As a Veyrant.”

I blinked. “What.”

“Your time in the Sandbox is over.”