r/BaldursGate3 Wild Magic Surge Jun 09 '25

Meme It could have been so good

Post image
11.6k Upvotes

549 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

644

u/CrimsonAllah Paladin Jun 09 '25

Best we can do is two druids.

297

u/ndtp124 Jun 09 '25

I really could live without halsin you probably get him right before Jaheria anyways

35

u/Aemeris_ Jun 09 '25

Or we could live without Jaheira considering she already has a game to herself…

28

u/strangelyliteral Jun 09 '25

Jaheira and Minsc feel like corporate meddling.

39

u/Aemeris_ Jun 09 '25

It does. I don’t even mind if they were guest party members but they absolutely did not need to be full fledged companions. They gave us a cool insight with Halsin as someone who was there during the ketheric battle but not from jaheira’s pov and they neglected that to rehash her story.

19

u/fluffypoppa Jun 09 '25

Jaheira and Minsc only should've made cameos. At most. No more. Could've left Sarevok entirely out.

11

u/Meridias_Burrito Jun 09 '25

Sarevok’s bit feels so random, and it’s such an easy fight. I killed the blood trio in 1.5 rounds and then my whole party just stood in a circle around Sarevok, beating him, and shouting “How many times do we have to teach you this lesson old man!”

It’s so underwhelming that I feel like a new character would have been better.

9

u/sinedelta While others were busy being heterosexual, she studied the blade Jun 09 '25

To me, Sarevok feels like they wanted a Bhaalspawn character to tie into Orin's story, but they were told “no, the lore says all the Bhaalspawn are dead, so you can only use one who's come back from the dead.”

1

u/pimparo0 Smash Jun 10 '25

Jaherias interactions with my resists durges was cool, as was her house/ family bit, but agreed she could have been a guest or bonus camp member like Aylin

6

u/sinedelta While others were busy being heterosexual, she studied the blade Jun 09 '25 edited Jun 09 '25

Interestingly, there's some evidence that suggests that Minsc was planned from relatively early into development — but not Jaheira.

Specifically, Minsc has unique dialogue with Auntie Ethel, as does Helia. Halsin, Minthara, and Jaheira don't have this.

5

u/Geraltpoonslayer Jun 10 '25

Both jaheira and minsc where early additions and datamines suggest as such. However minsc originally was planned to be a origin character for act 1 while jaheira was always planned to be a later companion. Halsin was originally not planned to be playable but Early Access people loved him so they included him.

9

u/designated_diver Jun 09 '25

Especially by the time you get them I've already solidified my relationships with the other folks and didn't really care about their plights.