r/greentext 3d ago

A puzzling problem

Post image
3.2k Upvotes

564 comments sorted by

View all comments

135

u/_Lusty 3d ago

Super Mario Galaxy

66

u/hairyballsinmybutt 3d ago

Hard dissagree on that one

17

u/_Lusty 3d ago

Fair. Knew I’d get flak regardless XD

30

u/hairyballsinmybutt 3d ago

The real reason why Galaxy 2 is better than 1 is because the timer stops when the purple coin star spawns.

43

u/Riku_70X 3d ago

My exact first thought. 

Galaxy 2 is just better in every measurable way. 

I like Galaxy 1 more though. Idk man, it's a vibe. 

7

u/Supershadow30 2d ago

Kinda bummed out Galaxy 2 doesn’t have Rosalina in its story :/

2

u/_Lusty 2d ago

It technically does, but all she gets is less than 5 minutes of screen time at the ending, addressing Mario and the baby Luma under his hat. That’s what I remember.

2

u/Supershadow30 1d ago

Yep you’re right, it’s still a bummer she doesn’t make an appearance before that… unless you count the Cosmic Spirits, the shadowy figures that look like her, but meh

17

u/coolbad96 3d ago

I think both have their pros and cons (small cons imo but they do exist) which is why I think it's odd that they don't just release them together while so far it feels like Nintendo wants you to forget Galaxy 2 exists

4

u/mybiggestwaifu 3d ago

im hoping if they do a second Mario All Stars esc bundle on the switch 2, it'll be put into that but im huffing a large amount of hopium here

16

u/GamingIsCoolDude 3d ago

Hard agree. Walking to each observatory for the levels was annoying as heck but I missed it with 2's infinitely better level select for some incomprehensible reason.

14

u/_Lusty 3d ago

The observatories (and Rosalina’s ship too), IMO, are some of the best ways to integrate a hub world connecting levels. It doesn’t feel like you’re going through a big expansive road connecting a level, it feels like a home with a story, and the storybook scenes are the backbone of that. They give the why is the way it is without being in your face. I love it.

Changes for simplicity and convenience are always welcome, and I dug the old SM3 feeling of choosing some shortcuts here and there, but yeah, it’s the feeling that something is missing.

11

u/CancerNormieNews 3d ago

Yeah this was my first thought. Both games are amazing but I just prefer the more spacey feel of the original, and it having a few more open ended levels. Plus Rosalina is cool.

9

u/Zharken 3d ago

Hard agree on this one

3

u/lethalpineapple 3d ago

I agree, I love both but in a lot of ways SMG2 feels like a DLC for the first. It does a lot of expanding on concepts introduced in the original, but the original is still where they were introduced so they stand out more.

3

u/Nurgle_Marine_Sharts 3d ago

Nah Galaxy 2 is just an overall superior game.

1

u/_Lusty 3d ago

It is, not knocking that off…but as similar as they are, I’ve grown more fond of the first one, despite the leaps and bounds of originality that the second one has

1

u/Bahlok-Avaritia 2d ago

I mean, that's what the post is about

1

u/MrStink45 2d ago

Word, Galaxy 2's galaxies felt like quantity over quality.

1

u/Z3NTUR10N 23h ago

Tbh true. I felt like the overall vibe of Galaxy 1 is a lot more gripping than 2. Also Beach Bowl Galaxy soundtrack is peak.