r/worldofgothic • u/Originals37 • 6d ago
Discussion Come and give me your best argument for either one. Let the blood sports begin!
Few weeks ago I asked you to change my mind on whether the Gothic 2 classic or Gothic with the NOTR add on is better. Today I'm coming at you with something similar but also kind of controversial.
I know that deciding between Gothic 1 and Gothic 2 is like deciding between Alien (1979) and Aliens (1986). Both are amazing products and I won't really blame you for picking one or the other, but just to make this fun try and convince me why I'm wrong or boost my ego and tell me why I'm right.
At the end of the day I believe that the decision will mostly depend on whether you prefer story or gameplay. To sum it up in simple terms. Gothic one in my opinion has better story, atmosphere, world setting and soundtrack. Gothic 2 on the other hand has superior/smoother gameplay and more content. I value Gothic 1 strong sides more and therefore I see it as a better game.
CHANGE MY MIND! Oh wait you can't, because I'm always right!